Pages

Monday, 5 March 2012

McCain: The case for U.S. airstrikes in Syria


Sen. John McCain (photo from queerty.com)

REMARKS BY SENATOR JOHN McCAIN ON THE SITUATION IN SYRIA ON THE FLOOR OF THE U.S. SENATE (March 5, 2012)
“After a year of bloodshed, the crisis in Syria has reached a decisive moment.
“It is estimated that more than 7,500 lives have been lost. The United Nations has declared that Syrian security forces are guilty of crimes against humanity, including the indiscriminate shelling of civilians, the execution of defectors, and the widespread torture of prisoners. Bashar Al-Assad is now doing to Homs what his father did to Hama. Aerial photographs procured by Human Rights Watch show a city that has been laid to waste by Assad’s tanks and artillery. A British photographer who was wounded and evacuated from the city described it as ‘a medieval siege and slaughter.’ The kinds of mass atrocities that NATO intervened in Libya to prevent in Benghazi are now a reality in Homs. Indeed, Syria today is the scene of some of the worst state-sponsored violence since Milosevic’s war crimes in the Balkans, or Russia’s annihilation of the Chechen city of Grozny.
“What is all the more astonishing is that Assad’s killing spree has continued despite severe and escalating international pressure against him. His regime is almost completely isolated. It has been expelled from the Arab League, rebuked by the United Nations General Assembly, excoriated by the U.N. Human Rights Council, and abandoned by nearly every country that once maintained diplomatic relations with it. At the same time, Assad’s regime is facing a punishing array of economic sanctions by the United States, the European Union, the Arab League, and others – measures that have targeted the assets of Assad and his henchmen, cut off the Central Bank and other financial institutions, grounded Syria’s cargo flights, and restricted the regime’s ability to sell oil. This has been an impressive international effort, and the Administration deserves a lot of credit for helping to orchestrate it.
“The problem is, the bloodletting continues. Despite a year’s worth of diplomacy backed by sanctions, Assad and his top lieutenants show no signs of giving up and taking the path into foreign exile. To the contrary, they appear to accelerating their fight to the finish. And they are doing so with the shameless support of foreign governments, especially in Russia, China, and Iran. A steady supply of weapons, ammunition, and other assistance is flowing to Assad from Moscow and Tehran, and as the Washington Post reported yesterday, Iranian military and intelligence operatives are likely active in Syria, helping to direct and sharpen the regime’s brutality. The Security Council is totally shut down as an avenue for increased pressure, and the recently convened Friends of Syria contact group, while a good step in principle, produced mostly rhetoric but precious little action when it met last month in Tunisia. Unfortunately, with each passing day, the international response to Assad’s atrocities is being overtaken by events on the ground in Syria.
“Some countries are finally beginning to acknowledge this reality, as well as its implications. Saudi Arabia and Qatar are calling for arming opposition forces in Syria. The newly-elected Kuwaiti parliament has called on their government to do the same. Last week, the Supreme Allied Commander of NATO, Admiral James Stavridis, testified to the Senate Armed Services Committee that providing arms to opposition forces in Syria could help them shift the balance of power against Assad. Most importantly, Syrians themselves are increasingly calling for international military involvement. The opposition Syrian National Council recently announced that it is establishing a military bureau to channel weapons and other assistance to the Free Syrian Army and armed groups inside the country. Other members of the Council are demanding a more robust intervention.
“To be sure, there are legitimate questions about the efficacy of military options in Syria, and equally legitimate concerns about their risks and uncertainties. It is understandable that the Administration is reluctant to move beyond diplomacy and sanctions. Unfortunately, this policy is increasingly disconnected from the dire conditions on the ground in Syria, which has become a full-blown state of armed conflict. In the face of this new reality, the Administration’s approach to Syria is starting to look more like a hope than a strategy. So, too, does their continued insistence that Assad’s fall is ‘inevitable.’ Tell that to the people of Homs. Tell that to the people of Idlib, or Hama, or the other cities that Assad’s forces are now moving against. Nothing in this world is pre-determined. And claims about the inevitability of events can often be a convenient way to abdicate responsibility.
“But even if we do assume that Assad will ultimately fall, that may still take a really long time. In recent testimony to the Senate Armed Services Committee, the Director of National Intelligence, James Clapper, said that if the status quo persists, Assad could hang on for months, possibly longer. And that was before Homs fell. So just to be clear: Even under the best-case scenario for the current policy, the cost of success will likely be months of continued bloodshed and thousands of additional lives lost. Is this morally acceptable to us? I believe it should not be.
“In addition to the moral and humanitarian interests at stake in Syria, what is just as compelling, if not more so, are the strategic and geopolitical interests. Put simply, the United States has a clear national security interest in stopping the violence in Syria and forcing Assad to leave power. In this way, Syria is very different than Libya: The stakes are far higher, both for America and some of our closest allies.
“This regime in Syria serves as the main forward operating base of the Iranian regime in the heart of the Arab world. It has supported Palestinian terrorist groups and funneled arms of all kinds, including tens of thousands of rockets, to Hezbollah in Lebanon. It remains a committed enemy of Israel. It has large stockpiles of chemical weapons and materials and has sought to develop a nuclear weapons capability. It was the primary gateway for the countless foreign fighters who infiltrated into Iraq and killed our troops. Assad and his lieutenants have the blood of hundreds of Americans on their hands. Many in Washington fear that what comes after Assad might be worse. How could it be any worse than this?
“The end of the Assad regime would sever Hezbollah’s lifeline to Iran, eliminate a long-standing threat to Israel, bolster Lebanon’s sovereignty and independence, and inflict a strategic defeat on the Iranian regime. It would be a geopolitical success of the first order. More than all of the compelling moral and humanitarian reasons, this is why Assad cannot be allowed to succeed and remain in power: We have a clear national security interest in his defeat. And that alone should incline us to tolerate a large degree of risk in order to see that this goal is achieved.
“Increasingly, the question for U.S. policy is not whether foreign forces will intervene militarily in Syria. We can be confident that Syria’s neighbors will do so eventually, if they have not already. Some kind of intervention will happen, with us or without us. So the real question for U.S. policy is whether we will participate in this next phase of the conflict in Syria, and thereby increase our ability to shape an outcome that is beneficial to the Syrian people, and to us. I believe we must.
“The President has characterized the prevention of mass atrocities as, quote, ‘a core national security interest.’ He has made it the objective of the United States that the killing in Syria must stop, and that Assad must go. He has committed the prestige and credibility of our nation to that goal, and it is the right goal. However, it is not clear that the present policy can succeed. If Assad manages to cling to power – or even if he manages to sustain his slaughter for months to come, with all of the human and geopolitical costs that entails – it would be a strategic and moral defeat for the United States. We cannot, we must not, allow this to happen.
“For this reason, the time has come for a new policy. As we continue to isolate Assad diplomatically and economically, we should work with our closest friends and allies to support opposition groups inside Syria, both political and military, to help them organize themselves into a more cohesive and effective force that can put an end to the bloodshed and force Assad and his loyalists to leave power. Rather than closing off the prospects for some kind of a negotiated transition that is acceptable to the Syrian opposition, foreign military intervention is now the necessary factor to reinforce this option. Assad needs to know that he will not win.
“What opposition groups in Syria need most urgently is relief from Assad’s tank and artillery sieges in the many cities that are still contested. Homs is lost for now, but Idlib, and Hama, and Qusayr, and Deraa, and other cities in Syria could still be saved. But time is running out. Assad’s forces are on the march. Providing military assistance to the Free Syrian Army and other opposition groups is necessary, but at this late hour, that alone will not be sufficient to stop the slaughter and save innocent lives. The only realistic way to do so is with foreign airpower.
“Therefore, at the request of the Syrian National Council, the Free Syrian Army, and Local Coordinating Committees inside the country, the United States should lead an international effort to protect key population centers in Syria, especially in the north, through airstrikes on Assad’s forces. To be clear: This will require the United States to suppress enemy air defenses in at least part of the country.
“The ultimate goal of airstrikes should be to establish and defend safe havens in Syria, especially in the north, in which opposition forces can organize and plan their political and military activities against Assad. These safe havens could serve as platforms for the delivery of humanitarian and military assistance – including weapons and ammunition, body armor and other personal protective equipment, tactical intelligence, secure communications equipment, food and water, and medical supplies. These safe havens could also help the Free Syrian Army and other armed groups in Syria to train and organize themselves into more cohesive and effective military forces, likely with the assistance of foreign partners.
“The benefit for the United States in helping to lead this effort directly is that it would allow us to better empower those Syrian groups that share our interests – those groups that reject Al-Qaeda and the Iranian regime, and commit to the goal of an inclusive democratic transition, as called for by the Syrian National Council. If we stand on the sidelines, others will try to pick winners, and this will not always be to our liking or in our interest. This does that mean the United States should go it alone. We should not. We should seek the active involvement of key Arab partners such as Saudi Arabia, U.A.E., Jordan, and Qatar – and willing allies in the E.U. and NATO, the most important of which in this case is Turkey.
“There will be no U.N. Security Council mandate for such an operation. Russia and China took that option off the table long ago. But let’s not forget: NATO took military action to save Kosovo in 1999 without formal U.N. authorization. There is no reason why the Arab League, or NATO, or a leading coalition within the Friends of Syria contact group, or all of them speaking in unison, could not provide a similar international mandate for military measures to save Syria today.
“Could such a mandate be gotten? I believe it could be. Foreign capitals across the world are looking to the United States to lead, especially now that the situation in Syria has become an armed conflict. But what they see is an Administration still hedging its bets – on the one hand, insisting that Assad’s fall is inevitable, but on the other, unwilling even to threaten more assertive actions that could make it so.
“The rhetoric out of NATO has been much more self-defeating. Far from making it clear to Assad that all options are on the table, key alliance leaders are going out of their way to publicly take options off the table. Last week, the Secretary-General of NATO, Mr. Rasmussen, said that the alliance has not even discussed the possibility of NATO action in Syria – saying, quote, ‘I don’t envision such a role for the alliance.’ The following day, the Supreme Allied Commander, Admiral James Stavridis, testified to the Senate Armed Services Committee that NATO has done no contingency planning – none – for potential military operations in Syria.
“That is not how NATO approached Bosnia. Or Kosovo. Or Libya. Is it now the policy of NATO – or the United States, for that matter – to tell the perpetrators of mass atrocities, in Syria or elsewhere, that they can go on killing innocent civilians by the hundreds or thousands, and the greatest alliance in history will not even bother to conduct any planning about how we might stop them? Is that NATO’s policy now? Is that our policy? Because that is the practical effect of this kind of rhetoric. It gives Assad and his foreign allies a green light for greater brutality.
“Not surprisingly, many countries, especially Syria’s neighbors, are also hedging their bets on the outcome in Syria. They think Assad will go, but they are not yet prepared to put all of their chips on that bet – even less so now that Assad’s forces have broken Homs and seem to be gaining momentum. There is only one nation that can alter this dynamic, and that is us. The President must state unequivocally that under no circumstances will Assad be allowed to finish what he has started, that there is no future in which Assad and his lieutenants will remain in control of Syria, and that the United States is prepared to use the full weight of our airpower to make it so. It is only when we have clearly and completely committed ourselves that we can expect other countries to do the same. Only then would we see what is really possible in winning international support to stop the killing in Syria.
“Are there dangers, and risks, and uncertainties in this approach? Absolutely. There are no ideal options in Syria. All of them contain significant risk. Many people will be quick to raise concerns about the course of action I am proposing. Many of these concerns have merit, but none so much that they should keep us from acting.
“For example, we continue to hear it said that we should not assist the opposition in Syria militarily because we don’t know who these people are. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton repeated this argument just last week, adding that we could end up helping Al-Qaeda or Hamas. It is possible the Administration does not know much about the armed opposition in Syria, but how much effort have they really made to find out – to meet and engage these people directly? Not much, it appears.
“Instead, much of the best information we have about the armed resistance in Syria is thanks to courageous journalists, some of whom have given their lives to tell the story of the Syrian people. One of those journalists is a reporter working for Al-Jazeera named Nir Rosen, who spent months in the country, including much time with the armed opposition. Here is how he describes them in a recent interview:  
“‘The regime and its supporters describe the opposition, especially the armed opposition, as Salafis, Jihadists, Muslim Brotherhood supporters, al-Qaeda and terrorists. This is not true, but it’s worth noting that all the fighters I met … were Sunni Muslims, and most were pious. They fight for a multitude of reasons: for their friends, for their neighborhoods, for their villages, for their province, for revenge, for self-defense, for dignity, for their brethren in other parts of the country who are also fighting. They do not read religious literature or listen to sermons. Their views on Islam are consistent with the general attitudes of Syrian Sunni society, which is conservative and religious.  
“‘Because there are many small groups in the armed opposition, it is difficult to describe their ideology in general terms. The Salafi and Muslim Brotherhood ideologies are not important in Syria and do not play a significant role in the revolution. But most Syrian Sunnis taking part in the uprising are themselves devout.’
“He could just as well have been describing average citizens in Egypt, or Libya, or Tunisia, or other nations in the region. So we should be a little more careful before we embrace the Assad regime’s propaganda about the opposition in Syria. We certainly should not let these misconceptions cause us to keep the armed resistance in Syria at arm’s length, because that is just self-defeating. And I can assure you that Al-Qaeda is not pursuing the same policy. They are eager to try to hijack the Syrian revolution, just as they have tried to hijack the Arab Spring movements in Egypt, and Tunisia, and Libya, and elsewhere. They are trying, but so far, they are failing. The people of these countries are broadly rejecting everything Al-Qaeda stands for. They are not eager to trade secular tyranny for theocratic tyranny.
“The other reason Al-Qaeda is failing in Tunisia, and Egypt, and Libya is because the community of nations, especially the United States, has supported them. We are giving them a better alternative. The surest way for Al-Qaeda to gain a foothold in Syria is for us to turn our backs on those brave Syrians who are fighting to defend themselves. After all, Sunni Iraqis were willing to ally with Al-Qaeda when they felt desperate enough. But when America gave them a better alternative, they turned their guns on Al-Qaeda. Why should it be different in Syria?
“Another objection to providing military assistance to the Syrian opposition is that the conflict has become a sectarian civil war, and our intervention would enable the Sunni majority to take a bloody and indiscriminate revenge against the Alawite minority. This is a serious and legitimate concern, and it is only growing worse the longer the conflict goes on. As we saw in Iraq, or Lebanon before it, time favors the hard-liners in a conflict like this. The suffering of Sunnis at the hands of Assad only stokes the temptation for revenge, which in turn only deepens fears among the Alawites, and strengthens their incentive to keep fighting. For this reason alone, it is all the more compelling to find a way to end the bloodshed as soon as possible.
“Furthermore, the risks of sectarian conflict will exist in Syria whether we get more involved or not. And we will at least have some ability to try to mitigate these risks if we work to assist the armed opposition now. That will at least help us to know them better, and to establish some trust and exercise some influence with them, because we took their side when they needed it most. We should not overstate the potential influence we could gain with opposition groups inside Syria, but it will only diminish the longer we wait to offer them meaningful support. And what we can say for certain is that we will have no influence whatsoever with these people if they feel we abandoned them. This is a real moral dilemma, but we cannot allow the opposition in Syria to be crushed at present while we worry about the future.
“We also hear it said, including by the Administration, that we should not contribute to the militarization of the conflict. If only Russia and Iran shared that sentiment. Instead, they are shamelessly fueling Assad’s killing machine. We need to deal with reality as it is, not as we wish it to be – and the reality in Syria today is largely a one-sided fight where the aggressors are not lacking for military means and zeal.
“Indeed, Assad appears to be fully committed to crushing the opposition at all costs. Iran and Russia appear to be fully committed to helping him do it. The many Syrians who have taken up arms to defend themselves and their communities appear to be fully committed to acquiring the necessary weapons to resist Assad. And leading Arab states appear increasingly committed to providing those weapons. The only ones who seem overly concerned about a militarization of the conflict are the United States and some of our allies. The time has come to ask a different question: Who do we want to win in Syria – our friends or our enemies?
“There are always plenty of reasons not to do something, and we can list them clearly in the case of Syria. We know the opposition is divided. We know the armed resistance inside the country lacks cohesion or command and control. We know that some elements of the opposition may sympathize with violent extremist ideologies or harbor dark thoughts of sectarian revenge. We know that many of Syria’s immediate neighbors remain cautious about taking overly provocative actions that could undermine Assad. And we know the American people are weary of conflict – justifiably so – and would rather focus on domestic problems.
“These are realities, but while we are compelled to acknowledge them, we are not condemned to accept them forever. With resolve, principled leadership, and wise policy, we can shape better realities. That is what the Syrian people have done.
“By no rational calculation should this uprising against Assad still be going on. The Syrian people are outmatched. They are outgunned. They are lacking for food, and water, and other basic needs. They are confronting a regime whose disregard for human dignity and capacity for sheer savagery is limitless. For an entire year, the Syrian people have faced death, and those unspeakable things worse than death, and still they have not given up. Still they take to the streets to protest peacefully for justice. Still they carry on their fight. And they do so on behalf of many of the same universal values we share, and many of the same interests as well.
“These people are our allies. They want many of the same things we do. They have expanded the boundaries of what everyone thought was possible in Syria. They have earned our respect, and now they need our support to finish what they started. The Syrian people deserve to succeed, and shame on us if we fail to help them.”

Lebanon’s pro-Assad Maronite Patriarch slammed


Maronite Patriarch Beshara Boutros al-Rai (phto from yalibnan.com)

Patriarch Beshara Boutros al-Rai, head of Lebanon’s Maronite Church, is accused once more of dancing with wolves over Syria. The blame comes today from Tariq Alhomayed, editor in chief of the leading Saudi daily Asharq Alawsat, after declarations the patriarch made in an interview with Reuters.
Rai was at the center of a nationwide political storm in Lebanon last September over controversial statements he made on Syria during a visit to France for talks with President Nicolas Sarkozy.
He told reporters at the time President Bashar al-Assad should be given a chance to carry out political reforms in the face of protesters demanding his ouster. He also warned the rise of the Muslim Brotherhood in Syria would threaten the presence of Christians there.
Here is what Alhomayed writes in his leader today:
The statements attributed by Reuters to Lebanon’s Maronite Patriarch Beshara Boutros al-Rai on the situation in Syria and on the status of Christians in the region are alarming.
Rai says, “How can it be an Arab Spring when people are being killed every day? They speak of Iraq and democracy, and one million Christians out of an original 1.5 million have fled Iraq.”
That’s a weird remark, for who drove out Iraq’s Christians? Al-Qaeda? If so, al-Qaeda wreaked havoc in Iraq with the support of Assad’s regime and Iran – the two patrons of Rai’s neighbor Hezbollah. Rai is probably unaware that Iran gave refuge to Osama Ben-Laden’s sons, Saif al-Adel and others. Isn’t it odd that Iraq’s Christians were in better circumstances under Saddam Hussein than they are today under Iran’s darling government of Nouri al-Maliki?
Aberrations in the Patriarch’s remarks don’t end here. He says, “Syria, like other countries, needs reforms which the people are demanding. It's true that the Syrian Baath regime is an extreme and dictatorial regime but there are many others like it in the Arab world,” adding: “All regimes in the Arab world have Islam as a state religion, except for Syria. It stands out for not saying it is an Islamic state ... The closest thing to democracy (in the Arab world) is Syria.”
That’s a provocative declaration that serves absolutely no one. Indeed, which Arab regime killed 10,000 of its citizens? Does Rai mean Moammar Gadhafi? Where is Gadhafi now? He got what he deserved and has met his God. Does he mean Saddam? And where is Saddam now? Does he mean Ali Abdullah Saleh? Also, where is he now? Or does he mean Hosni Mubarak and Zine El Abidine Ben Ali? They did nothing compared to Assad.
It is tragic if Rai perceives democracy as not declaring “Islam as a state religion.” It would mean the Patriarch is not troubled by the Syrians’ blood and supports Assad for leaving out the words “state religion is Islam.”
Even the Syrian opposition fared better than Rai by challenging a provision in the new Assad-drafted constitution that the president of Syria must still be a Muslim.
Rai’s words were accusatory and erroneous… His discourse was flawed because he implied that what was a “spring” in the region turned into a “winter” when the Syrians revolted. He echoes the position of Iran’s Supreme Leader, Hezbollah and the Maliki’s regime.
One final question to Rai: Who killed Lebanon’s leading Christian figures since 2005? Al-Qaeda?
It is so sad to see clerics, irrespective of their religions, turn their back on innocent souls!

China’s six-point peace roadmap for Syria


Beijing plan backs Kofi Annan's Syria mission

China has offered a six-point guideline to end the Syria crisis, calling for an immediate ceasefire and a “political solution” shepherded by Kofi Annan, the newly appointed UN-Arab League Joint Special Envoy for Syria.
The proposal released by the Chinese Foreign Ministry, warned other powers not to use humanitarian aid as a “pretext” to interfere “in Syria’s internal affairs.”
Following is the full English text of the six-point proposal, as carried by Xinhua news agency early Sunday Beijing time:
1. The Syrian Government and all parties concerned should immediately, fully and unconditionally cease all acts of violence, particularly violence against innocent civilians. Various factions in Syria should express political aspirations through non-violent means.

2. The Syrian Government and various factions should bear in mind the long-term and fundamental interests of their country and people, immediately launch an inclusive political dialogue with no preconditions attached or outcome predetermined through impartial mediation of the Joint Special Envoy of the United Nations (UN) and the Arab League (AL), agree on a comprehensive and detailed roadmap and timetable for reform through consultation and implement them as soon as possible with a view to restoring national stability and public order.
3. China supports the UN' s leading role in coordinating humanitarian relief efforts. China maintains that under the precondition of respecting Syria's sovereignty, the UN or an impartial body acceptable to all parties should make an objective and comprehensive assessment of the humanitarian situation in Syria, ensure the delivery and distribution of humanitarian aid. China is ready to provide humanitarian assistance to the Syrian people. We oppose anyone interfering in Syria' s internal affairs under the pretext of "humanitarian" issues.

4. Relevant parties of the international community should earnestly respect the independence, sovereignty, unity and territorial integrity of Syria and the right of the Syrian people to independently choose their political system and development path, create conditions and provide necessary and constructive assistance for the various political factions of Syria to launch dialogue, and respect the outcome of dialogue. China does not approve of armed interference or pushing for "regime change" in Syria, and believes that use or threat of sanctions does not help to resolve this issue appropriately.

5. China welcomes the appointment of the Joint Special Envoy on the Syrian crisis by the UN and the AL and supports him in playing a constructive role in bringing about the political resolution of the crisis. China supports the active efforts made by the Arab states and the AL to promote a political solution to the crisis.

6. Members of the Security Council should strictly abide by the purposes and principles of the UN Charter and the basic norms governing international relations. As a permanent member of the Security Council, China is ready to earnestly fulfill its responsibilities, engage in equal-footed, patient and full consultation with other parties on the political solution to the Syrian crisis in an effort to safeguard the unity of the Security Council.

Sunday, 4 March 2012

A look at the Tabriz carpet weaved for Syria


A Tabriz carpet (photo from goldenfingers.info)

I introduced Samir Atallah in a post last January saying his career as a journalist, writer and author spans almost half a century. A native of Lebanon, he has published several novels, historical books and travelogues. He now contributes a weekly think piece for Beirut’s an-Nahar and has been writing a daily column of about 300-400 words for Saudi Asharq Alawsat since 1987.

“Made in Tabriz” is the headline he chose for his column in today’s edition of Asharq Alawsat.

Here is how he encapsulates the Syria crisis:

Take a look from the perspective of the people of Tabriz: Russia (China too) sees America backpedaling and grudging the word “intervention.” Iran wants to inherit America’s weaknesses altogether. Syria is aware that the Russians know what they want to do and that the Americans know what they don’t want to do.

Russia and Iran are in luck – the Syrian field is first and last theirs, which explains the robotic birth of a Russian (Chinese)-Syrian-Iranian alliance. The partners are fighting back because they don’t have much to gain but a lot to lose: Russia without Syria is out of the Near East; and Iran without Syria blights its strategic and political expanse in Iraq and Lebanon, returning it to its pre-Islamic Revolution range.

This Tabriz carpet has numerous knots. Don’t forget that we are in Tabriz, where the higher the density of knots the more precious and expensive the rug becomes. And therein lies another contrast: whereas one group can see the knots and tell the number of strings used for the foundation of the rug, the other group sees the carpet but knows nothing about its strings. The Russian side is elated since it can rely on the insight of its Tabrizi partner.

The partner from Tabriz does not hide being the carpet owner. He decides the rhythm of negotiations and he will wink signal the final price when negotiators wear out in secret or in public.

Syria will thus have to await the result of the international tug-of-war, not the outcome of the debate over the intervention it rejected. Let’s not forget the words of the Prince of Diplomacy Walid al-Muallem wiping Europe off the world map.

We’re now in another phase. The carpet’s shady corners are being reworked with brighter colors. If the issue is struggle over Syria, Tabriz is the loom owner. America, on the other hand, finds no escape route other than the “Friends of Syria.” Russia (China too) is inside the circle of Syria & Co. And irrespective of happenings in Homs, the Russians are back talking about their role in the Palestinian issue and the Iranians about their power to wipe out Israel.

So the issue is not static. If you looked closely, you would see a Turkish carpet being woven. A pause follows the weaving of every section to consider what was achieved and what remains to be done. The Iranian doesn’t miss the chance to offer his expertise. The Russian invokes his neighborliness. Syrian oppositionists and loyalists listen to news and horror bulletins. And they reject intervention when they are in the heart of it already. 

Saturday, 3 March 2012

Women’s Day tribute to “my second mom”

Modern day Klayaa (Photo from klayaa.marjeyoun.net)
I thought I would acknowledge this year's International Women's Day (March 8) with a special tribute to "my second mom."
“Imm” or “Umm” means “the mother of” in Arabic.
Imm Nelly, née Maryam Sirhan, was a young woman when my maternal grandparents employed her as their housekeeper.
She came from Klayaa, a Christian Maronite village in South Lebanon adjoining the bustling town of Jdeidet Marjeyoun.
Snowbound Marjeyoun in 2008 (Photo from marjeyoun.net)
Maryam married a young man from her village and got pregnant when she was in her late teens. Halfway through her pregnancy, Maryam’s husband decided to migrate to Latin America, most probably Brazil, where he hoped to earn a living and support his wife and the child she was expecting.  She never heard from him again in her lifetime. But as soon as she gave birth to a daughter, Nelly, Maryam’s name changed to Imm Nelly.
She got to work for my grandparents as a single mother desperate to raise the apple of her eye, Nelly. Some years later, when my mother tied the knot and left my grandparents’ home, Imm Nelly followed her. “I came with your mother’s dowry,” she reminded me without fail.
Whatever money she earned throughout the 40-odd years of her working life with us went straight to Nelly. And after Nelly got married, she kept supporting her and her husband and their four offspring – two boys and two girls. As the household’s matriarch, she named the lot, one after the other. She called the eldest male “Hashem” and named her three other grandchildren after my mom, my younger sister and I.
When I asked her years later why she chose to give her first grandson a mainly Moslem name, “Hashem,” she simply said, “Because I like King Hussein and the Hashemites.”
The archetype of a hardworking, unfailingly honest, outspoken, strong-minded, God-fearing and devout mountain Maronite, Imm Nelly was deeply religious but not exactly a churchgoer. She sufficed with making the Sign of the Cross and invoking the Virgin Mary and St. Maron at all times. Her deep respect for the Moslem faith was because Islam regards Mary as one of the most righteous women. Also, she is cited more often in the Quran than in the entire New Testament.
I was in full-time employment but still working on my thesis for the Masters degree when Imm Nelly said one day it was high time she gave up work and retired in Klayaa. She also said she was yearning for a one-room annex or extension to her daughter’s modest home “where I can have my privacy and breathing space.” I helped realize her dream.
My sister and I cried our eyes out when she left. We felt we were parting with our second mom.
Some 12 years into her retirement, I sent after her to Beirut to see my three little boys, visit my office and chat with my staff. Though car drives never agreed with her (“they make me dizzy’), she showed up as planned. She kissed and cuddled my little boys, said they were lovely and shed a few tears. Then I asked her on our way to the office, “Imm Nelly, aren’t they beautiful?” Her curt response: “Nothing like you.”
I told my mainly female staff that I was bringing Imm Nelly along to the office. They were ready and received her with open arms. More tears. We then sat in a big circle in the conference room and I started telling her a word or two about each of the staff members in turn. She kept nodding without uttering a word – until I introduced my vivacious PA Leila Baroody, who was sporting a micro mini-skirt. Imm Nelly smiled and whispered lovingly in her ear: “Habibti (Darling), since we assembled in this room, you’ve been wriggling on your chair and pulling on your skirt to cover your thighs. Try lengthening the skirt when you get home.” (Leila is now happily married to a U.S. diplomat).
Imm Nelly snippets
Remedies
  • She had a mixed bag of old folk cures for common ailments. For headaches, she suggested applying a tad of tiger balm ointment to the forehead and temples and then using a good-sized handkerchief to tie firmly around the head. Her recommendation was also to avoid glaring sun in daytime and dim the lights at night. For constipation, she proposed downing either half a dozen fresh figs on an empty stomach first thing in the morning or five tablespoons of carob molasses blended with a bit of tahini. For tummy ache, she proposed a magic potion of three tablespoons of Arak diluted in a cup of tea with no sugar added. To stop bleeding, she applied ground coffee directly to the wound.

Religion
  • When she pampered me, especially at a young age, she would look me in the face and say tongue in cheek: “What lovely blond hair and blue eyes! Pity you were born a Moslem.”
  • To tease her, my father often recounted a joke about an unchaste monk. And each time he said “monk” she interjected the word “qadi.”  Then one day my father slipped while taking a shower and bruised his leg. Moments later, she told him, “God warned you this time. If you don’t desist from repeating ‘that’ joke he is bound to punish you. “
  • She appreciated my attendance of elective catechism classes in my Secondary years but made no comment on news of my sister’s marriage to a Maronite.
  • She believed the liturgical calendar of the Greek Orthodox is “unfailingly accurate” and that Lebanon’s Greek Orthodox and Moslems are “cousins.”

Politics
  • Her sympathy for France outlasted the end of the French mandate of Lebanon in 1943. Fourteen years later, she was furious when I came home from university one day soaked in water. Riot police hosed scores of students trying to break out from the American University of Beirut’s Medical Gate to protest the arrest by French troops of Algerian Revolution icon Jamila Bouhired. “Who is Jamila Bouhired to you?” she growled. “Don’t you know that she took up arms against France?”
  • She was lethargic to internal Lebanese politics. She had a one-line cliché reaction each time she heard of any local, parliamentary, or presidential election results in Lebanon: “Exit the satiated (government official), enter the famished,” she always said.

Friday, 2 March 2012

Syria recovers bodies of Colvin and Ochlik

State-run Syrian Arab News Agency (SANA) says the Syrian Army has today disinterred the bodies of two foreign journalists -- Marie Colvin of the United States and Javier Espinosa of Spain -- and French photographer Remi Ochlik after storming the Baba Amr district of Homs on Thursday.
Colvin and Ochlik were killed in the army’s mortar attacks on the neighborhood last week. But Espinosa is alive and tweeting (presumably from Beirut), “SANA mistake about my death can be based in my computer. I left everything on the spot when I had to run for my life.”
SANA said “competent authorities at Baba Amr” exhumed the bodies “following humanitarian-motivated strenuous efforts of search and follow up” after “foreign-backed armed terrorists” were flushed out of the area.
A foreign ministry source quoted by SANA said the bodies are to be transferred to a Damascus hospital for “DNA analysis, to be matched with DNA received from the victims respective countries, before being handed over to the embassies of Poland (representing U.S. interests in Syria), France and Spain the presence of Syrian Red Crescent and International Red Cross representatives.
The source offered “Syria’s condolences to the families of the three journalists,” hoping “foreigners would avoid entering the country illegally” and going to terrorist-controlled areas.
In its first statement on Syria in seven months, the UN Security Council yesterday deplored the rapidly deteriorating humanitarian situation in Syria and called on the government to grant UN humanitarian chief Valerie Amos "immediate and unhindered access.
Syria’s Champress today quotes a Syrian foreign ministry spokesman as saying, “We were surprised by Valerie Amos’ arrival in the region and her request to travel to Syria on a date that did not suit us. We are willing to consult with her on a mutually convenient date for her visit to Damascus.”
The Security Council press statement required agreement of all 15 Council members, including Russia and China, who vetoed two previous Syria resolutions.
Council President Mark Lyall Grant said, "The power of the statement is that it has all 15 members of the Security Council supporting it."
Full text of the press statement:
The members of the Security Council express their deep disappointment that the Syrian Government did not grant Ms. Valerie Amos, United Nations Under-Secretary-General for Humanitarian Affairs and Emergency Relief Coordinator, authorization to visit Syria in a timely manner, despite repeated requests and intense diplomatic contacts aimed at securing Syrian approval.  The members of the Security Council call upon the Syrian authorities to grant the coordinator immediate and unhindered access.
The members of the Security Council deplore the rapidly deteriorating humanitarian situation, in particular the growing number of affected civilians, the lack of safe access to adequate medical services, and food shortages, particularly in areas affected by fighting and violence such as Homs, Hama, Deraa and Idlib. 
The members of the Security Council call upon the Syrian authorities to allow immediate, full and unimpeded access of humanitarian personnel to all populations in need of assistance, in accordance with international law and guiding principles of humanitarian assistance.  They call upon all parties in Syria, in particular the Syrian authorities, to cooperate fully with the United Nations and relevant humanitarian organizations to facilitate the provision of humanitarian assistance and allow evacuation of the wounded from affected areas.

Thursday, 1 March 2012

Syrian airports said to be in SFA gunsights

Brig. Hossam Awak (Photo from Asharq Alawsat) 
Syrian airports will be targeted and closed by the opposition Syrian Free Army (SFA) before long, according to the SFA’s chief of military operations.

Brig. Hossam Awak, who served with the Syrian regime’s Air Force Intelligence before defecting tells the Saudi daily Asharq Alawsat in an exclusive interview: “We have sleeping cells strewn across Damascus ready for action… We will soon be carrying out operations in Damascus. We will also be closing the airports in Syria before long.”

Awak, who was interviewed for the newspaper by Amro Ahmad during a stopover in Cairo, said an Iranian armored brigade and Lebanese Hezbollah fighters are deployed in Syria to help quell the yearlong uprising.

“We have on Syrian territory a full armored brigade from the Iranian Revolutionary Guard. It is positioned in the camps of (PFLP-GC leader) Ahmad Jibril on the way to Deir El-Ashaer area near the Lebanese-Syrian border. This is being disclosed for the first time. The armored brigade was stationed there in 2007 in the wake of Hezbollah’s (2006) war with Israel.”

Awak said Hezbollah has so far committed three battalions to fight on the ground alongside the regime.

On Iraq, Awak said: “Candid information from Iraqi Kurdistan shows they sympathize with the Syrian revolution. Where the Nouri al-Maliki government is concerned, we honestly don’t know its stance. It seems to be a government that toes Iran’s line. But there hasn’t been any hostile attitude (towards the Syrian revolution). And even though they follow Iran, we hope they understand our situation since they also suffered under Saddam Hussein and the Baath regime.”

Awak went on, “Incoming Iraqi Shiite fighters are dealt with before arriving in Syria. We warn them for the umpteenth time: don’t meddle in Syrian affairs.”

Awak revealed the SFA received arms from Libya for a while, but this stopped because of Libya’s internal problems, adding: “I visited a number of the Gulf countries… where we were promised aid, but there is nothing new as yet. We’re waiting.”