Pages

Showing posts with label Arab League. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Arab League. Show all posts

Monday, 22 April 2013

Assad on Black Sunday: “U.S. remains pragmatic”


Syrian president tells visiting Lebanese group:
  • Americans have been pragmatic throughout the crisis
  • Europe is confused
  • For Russia, defending Damascus is defending Moscow’s status
  • The Arab League is blind as a bat
  • Lebanon is not in Africa to dissociate itself from Syria
  • The Aoun-Franjieh-Ra’i triplet is Lebanon’s godsend
  • The FSA is undone and we’re fighting al-Qaeda
  • The battle will be long and our sole choice is to win it

The Local Coordination Committees of Syria say government forces and militiamen loyal to President Bashar al-Assad killed a record 566 people, many of them women and children, across the country on Black Sunday.

At least 85 of the fatalities were in the town of Jdaidet al-Fadl near Damascus, which the army retook from opposition forces (see my April 16 post “Syrian army secures Damascus with ‘four walls’”).

At the same time, Assad was talking his fill on the Syria war to a deputation of supporters from Lebanon.
According to Beirut’s pro-regime daily al-Safir today, the Syrian president told his Lebanese loyalists at al-Muhajereen palace in Damascus the following:
Lebanon is not in Africa to dissociate itself from Syria
“Lebanon’s official policy of dissociation from the Syria war is misplaced. One cannot dissociate himself when he is in the line of fire and when the flames are approaching. I don’t understand! What does this policy mean exactly? Does it mean transposing Lebanon into Africa pending an end of the Syria crisis, when Lebanon would revert to its natural spot?”
The Aoun-Franjieh-Ra’i triplet is Lebanon’s godsend
Three Assad apologists -- Hezbollah ally Michel Aoun, the one-time Lebanese Army Commander who now leads the Free Patriotic Movement, MP and Marada Movement leader Suleiman Franjieh, and Maronite Cardinal Bechara Boutros al-Ra’i – are “farsighted, nationalist and insightful leaders…
“To Aoun’s credit, he tussled then made peace with us honorably. His position on the Syria crisis is so much more credible because he was not our friend in the past -- on the contrary, he was a vicious adversary. That’s why we recognize the value of his stance.
“As for MP Suleiman Franjieh, I can’t say more than he is my friend and my brother.
“Cardinal Ra’i is a guiding light.
“Aoun and Franjieh consolidate the Christians’ Eastern dimension and consecrate the Christians’ enrichment of the region’s social fabric.
“The same can be said of the Armenians who did not turn their back on Lebanon during its ordeal or on Syria now.
“While Islam blends us with the Kurds and the Arab identity binds us to the Christians, the Armenians succeeded in integrating our societies.”
The FSA is undone and we’re fighting al-Qaeda
“Developments on the ground are going well.
“Our strategy is to keep Damascus and the other cities under army control. As concerns the countryside, we deliberately choose to clear some areas for tactical reasons at times.
“Better we sap (their strength) than having them sap ours.
“The so-called Free (Syrian) Army is effectively undone. We’re now fighting al-Qaeda. Some 23 foreign nationalities are currently fighting on Syrian soil.
“Many advised us at the onset of the crisis to respond decisively. But you can’t do that to your own people on your home turf.
“Had we followed the counsel, the picture for some people would have looked blurred and we would have lost a few friends. Today, however, we are winning (the hearts and minds) of some of our adversaries.
“For example, we responded wisely when armed rebels broke into the Yarmouk Camp (for Palestinian refugees). We were urged to force them out.
“Instead, we reinforced our positions around the camp and fenced in the armed insurgents. In no time, we heard residents clamoring for the terrorists’ evictions from the camp…”
Generally, “the battle will be very long, but our sole choice is to win it.”
The Arab League is blind as a bat
“The Arab League is blind as a bat. It was originally set up to serve British interests. It never played a pan-Arab role, except in the days of Egypt’s late Gamal Abdel-Nasser.
For Russia, defending Damascus is defending Moscow’s status
“Moscow’s strategic decision to stand by the Syrian state is not for the love of our people and us. It is because Russia considers the battle to defend Damascus as a battle to defend the status and interests of Moscow.”
Today’s Russia is stronger than the former Soviet Union. Some people link the outcome of the Syria crisis to the meeting between Barack Obama and Vladimir Putin on the sidelines of the G8 summit in Northern Ireland in June.
“From our side, we say Syria’s steadfastness and strength will impact on the summit and not the other way around.  We need to impose our rhythm on the summit instead of vice versa. Each of the two presidents will be looking at the facts on the ground in Syria to determine what he does.”
Americans have been pragmatic throughout the crisis
“The Americans have been pragmatic since the onset of the crisis. They don’t go to the limit. In the end, they go along with the winner.
“Europe is confused.”


Wednesday, 17 April 2013

Lakhdar Brahimi: A fact, a buzz and a whisper

Kofi Annan, Lakhdar Brahimi and Mokhtar Lamani

THE FACT: Joint UN-Arab League troubleshooter Lakhdar Brahimi will Friday update the UN Security Council on the situation in Syria.
THE BUZZ: Brahimi hopes to be mandated as a UN envoy without any official link to the Arab League.
THE WHISPER: Brahimi will Friday do a Kofi Annan and be relieved by his deputy Mokhtar Lamani.
Brahimi, who is expected to offer the Security Council another bleak Syria report on Friday, reportedly feels the Arab League’s recognition of the Syrian opposition has undermined his role as a joint mediator.
"The joint special representative feels the Arab League approach makes it difficult for him to carry out his mandate," a diplomat told Reuters on condition of anonymity.
"He feels that it would be best to be associated only with the United Nations at this point to ensure his neutrality."
There have been rumors circulating for weeks that Brahimi might resign, though diplomats told Reuters his preference was to remain involved in Syrian peace efforts through the United Nations, an organization he has worked with for decades.
His predecessor, former U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan, resigned last August in frustration at the inability of the Security Council to unite behind his calls for an end to the violence and a peaceful political transition
The Syrian Opposition Coalition, recognized by the Arab League as the sole representative for Syria, attended the Arab summit and opened its first embassy in Doha last month in a diplomatic blow to President Bashar al-Assad’s regime.
Al-Akhbar journalist Radwan Mortada quotes unnamed sources as saying Brahimi’s resignation at Friday’s closed session of the Security Council “is now inevitable.” And Brahimi’s deputy Mokhtar Lamani would most likely take over the Syria peace-brokering mission.
Distinguished Moroccan career diplomat Lamani currently heads Brahimi’s Damascus office.
A Senior Visiting Fellow at the Center for International Governance Innovation (CIGI, Canada, Ontario), Lamani served in 2006 as Special Representative of the Arab League in Iraq, where he tried to persuade its bitterly divided Shiite, Kurdish and Sunni leaders to make peace. He failed and resigned in February 2007.
Mortada quotes extensively from a January 2007 think piece by al-Akhbar co-founder, the late Michel Samaha, blaming Lamani’s resignation then on feeble support from the Arab governments that hired him.
In his Jan. 22, 2007, resignation letter, a copy of which he gave to The Associated Press, Lamani said of the Iraqi leaders: "My only problem was their own relations with each other, their strong feeling that each is a victim of the other."
He also faulted the Arab League member-states, telling AP they did not give Iraq "the necessary priority or seriousness." Arab governments were so detached from Iraq that it was "as if it were on the moon," he said.

Thursday, 7 March 2013

Arab League allows members to arm the FSA

Syria's empty Arab League seat (top) and three dissenters, clockwise from R.:Medelci, Zibari and Mansour

Each of the 22 Arab League member states is now free to offer military aid to the Free Syrian Army (FSA) fighting forces loyal to President Bashar al-Assad.
The 22-member bloc also wants the Syrian National Coalition of Revolutionary and Opposition Forces “to form an executive body to take up Syria’s [Arab League] seat” and represent Syria at the impending Arab summit in about three weeks.
The league suspended Syria's membership in November 2011 after the Assad regime failed to abide by an Arab peace plan that sought to end the conflict.
Meeting in Cairo yesterday, the Arab League Council of Foreign Ministers resolved:
1. To reaffirm recognition of the Syrian National Coalition of Revolutionary and Opposition Forces as the sole representative of the Syrian people and the chief interlocutor with the League of Arab States.
2. To invite the Syrian National Coalition of Revolutionary and Opposition Forces to form an executive body to take up Syria’s seat at the Arab League, plus its organizations, councils and branches, and to participate in the upcoming two-day Arab League summit to be held in Doha on March 26-27. That will be the case until an elected government assumes office in Syria. This [decision] is in recognition of the Syrian people’s sacrifices and extraordinary circumstances.
3. To reaffirm continuation of the quest for a political solution to the Syrian crisis and to uphold the right of individual member states to offer, as they choose, all means of self-defense -- including military – to prop up the steadfastness of the Syrian people and Free Syrian Army.
4. To convene an international conference at the UN for rebuilding Syria.
The resolution carried three footnotes.
One said Algeria expressed a reservation on the second article.
Another said Iraq took issue with the second and third articles.
The last said Lebanon “dissociated” itself from the resolution altogether.
Algeria, Iraq and Lebanon were represented at the meeting by their respective foreign ministers – namely Mourad Medelci, Hoshiar Zebari and Adnan Mansour.
Syria’s own foreign ministry reacted by restating its "rejection of any role for the Arab League in a peaceful resolution of the crisis in Syria," accusing the League of being hostage to Qatar and Saudi Arabia and manipulated by the "monarchies of money, oil and gas."
Lebanon’s al-Akhbar, which speaks for Assad and Hezbollah, said “العرب للسوريين: اقتتِلوا”  -- i.e. the Arabs effectively tell Syrians to keep up their internecine warfare.
Al-Akhbar commentator Hassan Olayk separately defends Adnan Mansour, who represents the Shiite Amal Movement in the Beirut government. Olayk says the Lebanese foreign minister simply called for peace in warmongering times championed by oil-rich kingdoms.
By contrast, Rajeh el-Khoury, who writes for Lebanon’s independent daily an-Nahar, wonders: “Are we in the Republic of Lebanon or the independent Republic of Adnan Mansour, who yesterday stood at the Arab League and talk as if he were the foreign minister of Syria and Assad’s spokesman?”
The Arab League met in Cairo on the same day the UN refugee agency was saying the number of Syrians who have fled their war-ravaged country and are seeking assistance has now topped the one million mark.
"With a million people in flight, millions more displaced internally, and thousands of people continuing to cross the border every day, Syria is spiraling toward full-scale disaster," the UN High Commissioner for Refugees, Antonio Guterres, said in Geneva.
The Syria conflict is also depriving hundreds of thousands of children of their education.
Among findings in an education assessment conducted by UNICEF and released this week:
  • At least 2,400 schools have been damaged or destroyed, including 772 in Idlib (50 per cent of the total), 300 in Aleppo and another 300 in Deraa;
  • Over 1,500 schools are being used as shelters for displaced persons;
  • More than 110 teachers and other staff have been killed and many others are no longer reporting for work. In Idlib, for example, teacher attendance is no more than 55 per cent;
  • In Aleppo, children attendance rate has dropped to as low as 6 per cent.

Syria healthcare system has also collapsed, according to medical charity Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF).
MSF said in a report published today that hospitals, doctors and patients had come under direct attack, and many trained medical staff had fled abroad.
One-third of public hospitals are no longer functioning and healthcare has been forced underground, MSF said in a summary by the BBC .
The charity has more than 200 staff working in rebel-held areas of Syria.
It said repeated requests to the government for wider access had not been granted.
Despite its limited access, the charity said it had carried out more than 20,000 consultations and 1,560 surgical procedures since the start of the conflict in March 2011.
It has also opened three hospitals in opposition-held northern regions.
But MSF said the conflict had "made a mockery of the concept of healthcare".
"Medical aid is being targeted, hospitals destroyed and medical personnel captured," said MSF's Dr Marie-Pierre Allie.
The exodus of trained medical staff had left inexperienced workers trying to provide care, the charity said.
"Dentists are performing minor surgeries, pharmacists are treating patients and young people are volunteering to work as nurses," the report said.
Doctors had been labeled "enemies of the state" for treating the injured and both sides were now using hospitals as a war strategy, MSF said.
While government air raids targeted medical facilities, the rebels had begun to label their facilities "Free Syrian Army hospitals", increasing the risk of attack.
Increasingly, medical care has been forced underground, with makeshift hospitals set up in caves, homes and farms.
But MSF says these facilities are still being targeted in air raids.

Thursday, 31 January 2013

Syrian opposition chief stands in the line of fire


Moaz al-Khatib
Moaz al-Khatib is today facing calls to step down as head of the Syrian National Coalition of Revolutionary and Opposition Forces over his “unilateral offer” to negotiate with representatives of President Bashar al-Assad.
The resignation calls come after the Syrian National Council (SNC), a key component of the National Coalition, openly challenged Khatib’s conditional proposal.
The overt controversy broke out soon after Khatib posted Tuesday a statement on his personal Facebook page saying he would “sit face to face with Syrian regime representatives in Cairo or Tunis or Istanbul.”
He made the talks offer conditional on the Damascus government first releasing 160,000 detainees and renewing or extending for two years all Syrian exiles’ passports. (See last night’s post, “War of words breaks out in Syrian opposition ranks.”)
“Speaking in a personal capacity does not change the fact Khatib heads the National Coalition,” says Anas al-Abdah, a member of the SNC and chairman of the Movement for Justice and Development in Syria.
He tells today’s edition of Saudi Arabia’s leading daily Asharq Alawsat, “[Khatib] should have resigned before broaching such a sensitive issue. As head of the National Coalition, he should have consulted its members first.
“By failing to do so as Coalition leader, he proved to be short of political and leadership maturity and lacking political experience…
“I urge him to reconsider his position as Coalition leader.”
The SNC’s Ibrahim Merei, whose London-based Barada TV has been focusing on issues of democracy, human rights, youth activism and civil society empowerment since April 2009, tells Asharq Alawsat:
“I stand by the revolutionary forces… Whoever represents them should preclude direct or indirect talks with the regime...
“Khatib’s remarks are a betrayal of the blood of people killed in Syria. I urge him to retract... If he is coming under international pressure, he can simply pull out.”
A third reaction comes from Obeida Faris, head of the Arab Foundation for Development and Citizenship (AFDC).
He tells the paper: “Syrians sacrificed over 60,000 martyrs, more than two million refugees and exiles as well as tens of thousands of detainees. This was not to win a loaf of bread or renew passports.
“Passports were denied to tens of thousands of Syrians for several decades. But that didn’t drive them to sit down with a bloodstained regime that committed more crimes than any other serial killer in history.
“I can understand the humanitarian pressure the National Coalition leader is coming under… But concessions need not exceed red lines set by the National Coalition.”
Faris was specifically referring to two provisions in the agreement that founded the National Coalition in Doha last November.
The two provisions are: “(1) The sides agree to bring down the regime and all its symbols and mainstays, to disband the regime’s security services and to call to account those responsible for crimes against Syrians, and (2) The Coalition commits not to engage in any dialogue or negotiation with the regime.” (See my November 11, 2012, post, “The Syrian opposition’s Doha agreement.”)
Editorially, the publisher and editor-in-chief of the pan-Arab daily al-Quds al-Arabi, Abdelbari Atwan, today writes of “Khatib’s bombshell shattering the Syrian scene.”
Sheikh al-Khatib is neither ignorant nor naïve, says Atwan. He only aired his initiative after taking stock of information and facts gathered at two international conferences he attended this month. They are the January 9-10 meeting hosted by the Foreign and Commonwealth Office to galvanize international support for a Syrian-led transition to a stable democratic country and the January 28 “Friends of Syria” conference in Paris.
“He heard the opinions of both guests and hosts at the two venues. And the opinions simply dashed his hopes, chiefly as regards the supply of qualitative weapons to the opposition.”  
Atwan continues:
“Multiple reasons must have prompted Khatib to air his initiative, which could see him resign after coming in for a lot of shameless flak, or which could see a breakup of the Syrian opposition with the SNC choosing to opt out of the National Coalition.”
Atwan encapsulates the multiple reasons as follows:
1. The definitive rejection by the West -- chiefly the United States – of the idea of arming the Free Syrian Army and other rebel groups coupled with an explicit warning to the Gulf States not to fund or arm the rebels.
2. Barack Obama’s upbeat proclamation in his second inaugural speech earlier this month that “a decade of war is now ending.”
3.  The Syria crisis stagnating after the regime’s failure to overcome the armed opposition and the latter’s inability to bring down the regime by force.
4. A misreading by the opposition’s Arab and other backers of the regime’s resilience and Russia and Iran’s unbounded support of Assad.
5. A rise in the clout of Jihadists on the ground, especially in northern Syria, and their success in recruiting thousands of young Syrians and in offering social welfare services in areas under their control, which is what the Taliban did earlier in Afghanistan.
6. The acquiescence of most Arab countries supportive of the armed opposition that a peaceful transition is the way out of the crisis. The consequence is acceptance of the regime – albeit for a short period – and opening the door of dialogue with it.
7. Mothballing of the Syria file by the Arab League and its foreign ministers.
“Sheikh Moaz al-Khatib grasps all that,” Atwan writes. “But, above all,  he realizes that the international community has started to address the Syria crisis as an issue of refugees, rather than the cause of a people seeking reform, democratic change and the removal of a dictatorship.
“The just-concluded conference in Kuwait of international donors for Syria, where more than a billion dollars were pledged for Syrian refugees, is proof of the new turnaround.
“The focusing on humanitarian and apolitical aspects by Arab and foreign countries under the sponsorship of the United Nations and its secretary-general evokes memories of a similar approach 65 years ago to the Palestine Question. That’s when the ‘Question’ became one of refugees deserving relief aid in their host countries…”

Monday, 10 December 2012

Syria endgame: No transition without Assad leaving


What was Syria troubleshooter Lakhdar Brahimi cooking with senior U.S. and Russian officials in Geneva yesterday?
Apparently fish – and the editor-in-chief of the leading Saudi daily Asharq Alawsat doesn’t like the unpleasant odor.
Brahimi and Assad (top) and Lavrov and Clinton
Tariq Alhomayed suspects the three sides are working on a “distorted Yemen template” for the endgame in Syria that would keep President Bashar al-Assad in place until 2014.
Brahimi said in a statement the meeting with Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Mikhail Bogdanov and U.S. Deputy Secretary of State William Burns was “constructive and held in a spirit of cooperation.
“It explored avenues to move forward a peaceful process and mobilize greater international action in favor of a political solution to the Syrian crisis.
“All three parties reaffirmed their common assessment that the situation in Syria was bad and getting worse. They stressed that a political process to end the crisis in Syria was necessary and still possible.”
Sunday's meeting followed talks held last week in Dublin between Brahimi, U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov at which the three officials agreed on the urgent need to initiate a political process to end the conflict in Syria.
Participants at yesterday's meeting agreed that a political solution would be based on the core elements of the communiqué issued by the Action Group that met in Geneva on June 30.
The communiqué called for “The establishment of a transitional governing body, which can establish a neutral environment in which the transition can take place. That means that the transitional governing body would exercise full executive powers. It could include members of the present government and the opposition and other groups and shall be formed on the basis of mutual consent.” (See full text of the communiqué in my June 30 post, “Syria Action Group leaves open Assad question”)
The Action Group is made up of the UN and Arab League secretaries-general; the foreign ministers of the five permanent members of the Security Council and of Turkey, Qatar, Iraq and Kuwait; and the European Union’s high representative for foreign affairs and security policy.
In his leader for today’s edition of Asharq Alawsat, which I paraphrase below, Alhomayed writes:
Arab League Secretary-General Nabil Elaraby promises the Syria crisis is drawing to an end.
The Qataris in turn are optimistic about an American-Russian rapprochement regarding Syria following the Geneva meeting.
So what’s happening?
Sources tell me a Russian proposal is on the table whereby a transitional government is set up. Assad would have no powers over it and it would exclude anyone from his regime whose hands are stained with Syrian blood.
A prominent member of the opposition would head such a transitional government. Accordingly, Assad would stay put in Damascus until 2014. He would not run in the 2014 presidential elections. He would simply call it a day and go home. That’s the scenario I heard.
Of course, the Russians keep reiterating their stance on Syria.
So my question is: If the Russians are not changing their position, insisting they are not holding talks on the fate of embattled Assad, why are the Americans and Brahimi meeting with them? Why are the Qataris and Elaraby optimistic?
Elaraby says he hopes the U.S. and Russia can reconcile their views over Syria in order to prepare a resolution for the UN Security Council, which “will send a clear message to the (Assad) regime that it is no longer protected.” He also says the Syrian opposition could be a substitute for the regime in due time.
So what justifies the optimism and the statements if the Russian position remains unchanged?
In light of the aforesaid, there’s obviously an attempt to apply in Syria today the Gulf template used in Yemen. But the template has been distorted, presumably to preempt Assad’s recourse to chemical weapons.
Obviously, it is a waste of time if in fact Brahimi and the American and Russian officials are considering a transitional government that keeps Assad at the helm until 2014.
That would also be an effort to absolve Assad of all the crimes he committed, instead of showing him the door.
Syrians would find it adequate if Assad’s exit to this or that safe haven were synchronized with the kickoff of the transition.
But waiting until 2014 means bailing out Assad and recognizing him as president despite the death toll on his watch. Such a solution is surely unenforceable.
A solution that sees Assad stepping down and staying in Syria – à la Abdullah Saleh, who stayed in Yemen after standing down as president – is also totally unacceptable.
With the Free Syrian Army now positioned at the doorsteps of Damascus, and Assad’s regime on its knees, it is difficult to fathom a solution to the Syria crisis that does not see Assad hitting the road – not in one or two years, but now.

Wednesday, 14 November 2012

France puts U.S., UK & Arabs in the shade on Syria

French President Hollande at his press conference

France Tuesday became the first Western country to formally and unequivocally recognize Syria's newly formed National Coalition of Syrian Revolutionary and Opposition Forces as “the sole legitimate representative of the Syrian people.”
President François Hollande announced the move at his first televised news conference at the helm in Paris.
He told reporters at the Élysée Palace, “I announce today that France recognizes the Syrian National Coalition as the sole legitimate representative of the Syrian people and thus as the future transitional government of a democratic Syria, allowing it to bring down the curtain on Bashar al-Assad's regime. Wherever liberated zones are established, they should come under its [the Coalition’s] authority.”
Hollande said France would look at the question of arming the Coalition, but that it would not support doing so "as long as it wasn't clear where these weapons went".
"With the Coalition, as soon as it is a legitimate government of Syria, this [arming] question will be looked at by France, but also by all countries that recognize this government," he said.
The Obama administration’s attitude vis-à-vis the Syrian opposition body it helped create in Doha earlier this week remains overtly ambivalent.
U.S. State Department spokesman Mark Toner told Tuesday’s press briefing Washington recognized the National Coalition as a legitimate representative, but stopped short of describing it as a sole representative, saying the group must first demonstrate its ability to represent Syrians inside the country.
Here is how Toner put it:
“We did issue a statement the other day congratulating the representatives of the Syrian people who gathered in Doha for their formation of the National Coalition for Syrian Revolutionary and Opposition Forces. We look forward, obviously, to supporting the National Coalition as it charts a course for the end of Assad’s bloody rule and marks the start, we believe, of a peaceful, just, and democratic future for the people of Syria.
“Obviously, we’re going to work with them in the coming days to ensure that our humanitarian and nonlethal assistance serves the needs of the Syrian people. In answer to your – in direct answer to your question, what happens now or what are you looking for next, I think we now have a structure in place that can prepare for a political transition, but that we’re looking for it to still establish the types of technical committees that will allow us to make sure our assistance gets to the right places, both nonlethal and humanitarian…
“We do think this is a legitimate representative of the Syrian people, that it does reflect the Syrian people, as we talked about, that diverse group of Syrian people. We think it meets those needs. I think as we move forward though, we’re going to look to see it, as I said, finalize the establishment of its organizational structures. We also want to see that it has a demonstrated ability to represent Syrians within Syria. I think that’s another aspect we’re going to look at…”
The United Kingdom was far more evasive than the United States.
British Foreign Minister William Hague, speaking at the Arab League in Cairo on the same day as Hollande and Toner, said the opposition Coalition must gain support from within Syria.
"That is a very crucial consideration, and if they do these things well then yes we would then be able to recognize them as the legitimate representatives of the Syrian people," he said.
France has now gone further than even the Arab League and Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) in their respective recognitions of the opposition Coalition.
While Paris recognized it as “the sole legitimate representative of the Syrian people,” the League of Arab states described it simply as “the legitimate representative and principal interlocutor with the Arab League.”
The Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) grouping Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Kuwait, Bahrain, the UAE and Oman spoke softheartedly of the new Syrian body as “the legitimate representative of the brotherly Syrian people.”

Thursday, 23 August 2012

Wither Syria


Syria's death toll stands at 26,728 (syrianshuhada.com)

Ghassan Charbel, editor-in-chief of pan-Arab daily al-Hayat, penned this op-ed in Arabic
What remains of Syria
  • when her seat at the Arab League stays vacant and Arabs get used to her absence?
  • when her membership in the Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) is suspended (at the Mecca summit) in the presence of Iranian President Mahmud Ahmadinejad?
  • when 133 member states of the UN General Assembly vote in favor of a resolution urging her government to begin a political transition to end her ordeal?
What remains of Syria
  • when a despairing Khaled Meshaal walks out on her after failing to convince her political leadership that politics, not violence, is the way forward to a solution and that a revolution is taking place and not excesses by armed gangs?
  • when the “Axis of Resistance” loses its sole Sunnite limb that gave it access to Gaza and the heart of the Palestinian-Israeli conflict?
What remains of Syria
  • when a Lebanese security branch dares arresting former government minister Michel Samaha after catching him red-handed smuggling explosives?
  • when Lebanese mass media say Samaha was given the haul of explosives by the topmost Syrian security officer?
  • when Michel Aoun falls remorsefully silent because Samaha was his road guide to Damascus, the roots of St. Maroun and the coalition of minorities?
What remains of Syria
  • when her army tanks blitz neighborhoods of Damascus, which was renowned as the region’s most secure and stable capital city?
  • when her warplanes pound Aleppo or obliterate a village here and another there?
What remains of Syria
  • when her citizens cram refugee camps in Jordan, queue for food rations in refugee camps in Turkey, or huddle in fear or grief in Lebanon’s north, Bekaa Valley and capital?
What remains of Syria
  • when her humanitarian crisis is one of the worst worldwide?
  • when 2.5 million of her citizens need urgent humanitarian assistance?
  • when another 1.5 million Syrians have been forcibly displaced from their homes?
  • when horrific killings become a daily sight and when decapitated bodies don’t make news headlines anymore?
What remains of Syria
  • when Baathists flee rural areas for fear of workers and peasants they previously claimed to represent ?
  • when thousands of officers and soldiers announce their defections from their army on TV screens?
  • when eyes refuse to even catch sight of shabbeeha wrongdoings?
What remains of Syria
  • when an explosion decapitates her security chiefs at their nerve center?
  • when a committed Baathist (Riad Hijab) accepts his designation as prime minister only to start planning his defection?
  • when the world is busy finding out who got killed, who defected and who is preparing to jump ship?
What remains of Syria
  • when her future becomes subject to a decision by Vladimir Putin, Iran’s supreme leader and (Hezbollah chief) Hassan Nasrallah with the acquiescence of the Iraqi prime minister after being their trump card and representing their strategic depth?
  • when all you hear after opening a map of the country is talk of mini-states and sectarian islets?
  • when roving fighters breach her borders, causing a problem for her insurgents and a future tragedy for the country?
It is an open secret the Syria we know is no more. The Syria of extortionate security and absolute solidity, Syria the juggler of cards outside her borders, Syria who had veto power on Palestinian and Lebanese matters and could manipulate Iraq, Jordan and Turkey’s stability has vanished.
Syria will most probably sink into a merciless civil war and her social fabric will be ripped apart. She will emerge from the long, nightmarish cycle of violence bloodied, frail and jerked around in a deadly struggle between Syrians and regional and international players vying to shape her future.
We’re sort of bidding farewell to the Syria we know. And whether healthful or ailing, Syria is in the habit of leaving her mark on the region.