Pages

Showing posts with label Jordan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jordan. Show all posts

Sunday, 30 June 2013

Assad forces focus on Homs, rebels on Deraa


Khalid ibn al-Walid Mosque (top) under shelling
Khalid ibn al-Walid mausoleum (top) and before and after snaps of the mosque courtyard

Syrian President Bashar al-Assad’s forces were today using their lethal monopoly on the skies to launch recurring airstrikes against rebel-held districts in the central city of Homs.
The Syrian Opposition Coalition warned this afternoon the regime might resort to chemical weapons, having failed so far to make “any significant progress on the ground” in the battle for Homs, center of the 27-month-old uprising.
Activists said jets and mortars pounded rebel-held areas of the city that have been under siege by Assad's troops for a year, and soldiers fought battles with rebels in several districts.
An activist in Homs told The Associated Press the assault was "the worst campaign against the city since the revolution began" in mid-March 2011.
"Government forces are trying to storm (Homs) from all fronts," another activist told Reuters.
Video footage uploaded by activists on YouTube showed heavy explosions and white clouds of smoke rising from rebel districts.
One clip showed thick black smoke rising from the 13th-century Khalid ibn al-Walid Mosque, on the edge of the Khalidiya neighborhood.
The mosque is dedicated to Khalid ibn al-Walid, a companion of Prophet Muhammad and a military commander who led the Muslim conquest of Syria in the 7th century following the decisive Battle of Yarmouk, which put an end to Byzantine rule in Syria. His dome-topped mausoleum is located in a corner of the prayer hall.
The regime’s attack on Homs follows military advances by Assad forces, backed by Lebanese Hezbollah fighters, in villages in Homs province and towns close to the Lebanese border.
Three weeks ago Hezbollah spearheaded Assad's recapture of the town of Qusayr on the Lebanese-Syrian border.
Last Wednesday the rebels lost Tal Kalakh, a town located within walking distance of the Lebanon border.
Elsewhere in Syria rebels made major advances in the southwestern city of Deraa, just north of the border with Jordan.
They overran a major military checkpoint in Deraa on Friday and hoped it would allow them to capture the city, cradle of their 27-month-old uprising and an arms pipeline for rebels stretching all the way to Damascus.
According to military strategy expert Safwat al-Zayyat, a former major general in the Egyptian armed forces, “the battle for Homs is the regime’s follow-on to the Qusayr battle.”
Zayyat told Aljazeera TV in an interview last night:
The regime’s focus now is to try and regain full control of Homs.
The rebels, on the other hand, have the initiative in Aleppo and in the battles for Idlib and for Deraa.
Assad forces know the airbases they use for resupply from Iran and Russia are liable to be bombarded at anytime.
They thus want to secure an alternative bridgehead for resupply from their allies in Lebanon.
The regime wants to consolidate its control over a corridor of territory into Lebanon that runs from Damascus through Homs to Qusayr and Tal Kalakh.
Lebanon is set to become the regime’s next and sole resupply artery.
By concentrating their firepower on Jurat al-Shiah, Khalidiya, Bab al-Sebaa, Bab Houd and Bab al-Drayb in Homs, Assad forces are unlikely to want to overrun these neighborhoods. They don’t have the foot soldiers to do that. They would want to decimate and cleanse the neighborhoods instead.
As regards the rebels, they are on the verge of a decisive victory in Deraa shortly. Now that they have overrun military checkpoints Nos. 35, 36 and 37, the only neighborhood standing in their way into Deraa city center is al-Manshieh.
By capturing Deraa, opposition forces would be able to rush reinforcements to rebels fighting in Eastern Ghouta and the southern districts of Damascus.
In brief, the rebels now control most of Syria’s north and a sizable part of its south, and the regime is in the saddle in the provinces of Homs and Damascus.  

Thursday, 27 June 2013

Why Geneva-2 on Syria is a dead duck

Obama arms Syrian rebels (www.hawaiireporter.com)

According to today’s Wall Street Journal, “The Central Intelligence Agency has begun moving weapons to Jordan from a network of secret warehouses and plans to start arming small groups of vetted Syrian rebels within a month, expanding U.S. support of moderate forces battling President Bashar al-Assad, according to diplomats and U.S. officials briefed on the plans.
“The shipments, related training and a parallel push to mobilize arms deliveries from European and Arab allies are being timed to allow a concerted push by the rebels starting by early August, the diplomats and officials said, revealing details of a new covert plan authorized by President Barack Obama and disclosed earlier this month.
“The CIA is expected to spend up to three weeks bringing light arms and possibly antitank missiles to Jordan. The agency plans to spend roughly two weeks more vetting an initial group of fighters and making sure they know how to use the weapons that they are given, clearing the way for the first U.S.-armed rebels to enter the fight, diplomats briefed on the CIA's plans said.
“Talks are under way with other countries, including France, about pre-positioning European-procured weapons in Jordan. Saudi Arabia is expected to provide shoulder-fired antiaircraft missiles, known as MANPADs, to a small number of handpicked fighters, as few as 20 at first, officials and diplomats said. The U.S. would monitor this effort, too, to try to reduce the risk that the MANPADs could fall into the hands of Islamists.
“Up to a few hundred of the fighters will enter Syria under the program each month, starting in August, according to diplomats briefed on CIA plans.
“At that rate, U.S. and Saudi officials believe it would take four to five months before there are enough rearmed and trained moderate fighters to make a meaningful difference against Assad's forces and their Hezbollah allies, according to diplomats and U.S. officials…”
Writing today for the pan-Arab newspaper al-Hayat, Lebanese political analyst Abdelwahhab Badrakhan explains why talk of a political solution in Syria anytime soon is haywire:
At the dawn of the revolution, Syria-watchers expected the regime to propose a live-and-let-live compromise to weather the storm, if not to take the wind out of the sails of protesters.
The Syria-watchers were citing previous instances when the regime caved in and agreed terms set by previous adversaries such as Israel, Turkey’s military and Washington.
The regime will now do the same to live on and avoid a losing war against its people, they were saying.
The Syria-watchers were proven wrong when the regime refused to cede an inch to its opponents and chose to engage them in a do-or-die struggle.
A year-and-a-half later, some people thought Iran, which was backing the regime and milking Iraq to fund it, would use her pragmatism and realism to check Damascus’ recklessness, having failed to use backroom talks on her nuclear program to save it. She did not.
Iran chose not to build on Russia’s and some Western states’ amenability to Assad to thrash out a reasonable denouement to the crisis.
Instead, she dovetailed Assad’s plans and supplemented them with an undertaking to foil the “conspiracy against the Axis of Resistance.”
Iran’s fervor to “ignite the region” and stoke the fires of sectarianism now surpass the regime’s zeal. She had no qualms about turning Hezbollah forces into guns-for-hire and contract killers in Syria and Lebanon.
Until the past few weeks, there were also people who thought change would turn up in Moscow.
Russia is a Big Power carrying the responsibility to protect (R2P). She is aware that her and the others’ talk of external “interventions” is sheer manipulation of the crisis. Proof is that at no one stage did the regime truly and directly risk being overthrown.
Moreover, in their uninterrupted contacts, the Americans let the Russians know that the West did not intend to intervene in Syria and that a political solution was and remains the immutable goal of the Obama Administration.
The Russians refuse to play ball. It serves them well to let the crisis drag on and to persevere in rubbing the West’s nose so long as the regime holds out.
By insisting to manage the crisis, Russia finds herself adopting the policies of a rogue state with a mindset cloned from Iran and Syria.
All this to say that waiting for a political solution anytime soon is like waiting for Godot -- it is simply not on the regime or its two principal partners’ mind.
G7 leaders must have felt this from their Russian partner at the G7+1 summit in Northern Ireland.
They must have realized their Russian partner wants to use them as tools to continue the Syria war.
He is their partner in the war on the “terrorists” he uses against them.
He is the G7’s partner in figuring an end to the crisis. But he is also the partner of the Syrian and Iranian regimes in distancing that end pending their victory on the battleground.
He is the G7’s partner in the search for stability in the region. But he is also the partner of the Syrian and Iranian regimes in plans to overwhelm the G7’s Arab allies.
He is their partner in forestalling sectarian conflicts in and around Syria. But he is also the partner of the Syrian and Iranian regimes in stoking the fires of religious wars.
G7 leaders were made aware their Russian partner is not interested in Geneva-2 unless it upholds the regime in one way or another.
Washington’s decision to arm Syrian opposition forces and to re-balance their fight with the regime and bring about a diplomatic solution when none is in sight is like a blind man in a dark room looking for a black cat that isn’t there.

Saturday, 22 June 2013

“You’re not helping me cast out sectarian bigotry”


Saudi national flag (top) and a Shiite banner 

By Jamal Khashoggi, Saudi Arabia’s authoritative political analyst, author and kingpin of the impending Al Arab TV news channel, writing in Arabic today for the mass circulation newspaper al-Hayat
If we were to map out Syrian regime supporters, we would regrettably find them mirroring the minority Shiite population’s distribution in the Muslim world.
In this, we are excepting a few voices heard here and there.
Among them, for instance, are Shiite intellectuals in Lebanon issuing a statement, or Hezbollah defectors going live on Arab TV networks, to declare the party does not represent them.
Or to express concern their community is being dragged into a sectarian conflict for which they would have to pay in a predominantly Sunni environment representing most of the Ummah.
The aforesaid exceptions prove, rather than undermine, the premise.
On the fringes of this Shiite landmass stretching from Iran to Iraq and Lebanon, there are in Arab capitals tiny and hardly discernible patches of nationalist intellectuals, Nasserite politicians, or Baathists rooting for Bashar al-Assad.
They also parrot the theory of an American-Zionist conspiracy aimed at undermining the bastion of contrariety and resistance and the ultimate Arab army.
Like the Shiite fundamentalists shepherding the Shiite general public to back Syria’s regime, they do not see the limpid, unobstructed and good-sized “banner of freedom” the Syrian people have been raising for more than two years.
But they clearly notice the Takfiris, the eaters of human organs and the suicides.
They make these out to be the Syrian Revolution, which at heart is nationalist, Islamist, moderate, broad-based and genuinely representative of all spectrums of the Syrian population.
Yes, there are Takfiris linked to al-Qaeda and to hardline Salafist currents fighting in Syria.
True, they are motivated by their hatred of Shiism, modernism and all “The Other.”
They don’t strive for democracy or a modern civil state in which all Syrians are equal.
They can’t be part of a Syrian national body politic, whether headed by a turbaned sheikh or its current leader George Sabra.
They are the same underground movements Syrian Intelligence used to send to Iraq, prompting Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki (in 2009) to press for the trial of Syria-based terrorists by a UN tribunal.
That was two or three years before the outbreak of Syria’s uprising.
The uprising saw Maliki bury old differences, switch sides, and become Bashar’s partner – a bizarre turnaround that can only be explained by sectarian motives.
Thieves, highway bandits and opportunists joined the mavericks infiltrating the Syrian revolution since revolutions don’t attract honorable people only.
But to put those in the spotlight is sheer escapism, which Bashar cheerleaders use in order to justify turning their back on a bona fide revolution against a tyrant and a repressive regime that people have been itching to bring down for decades.
Bashar’s non-Shiite disciples, on the other hand, can find an excuse for their evildoing.
For example, Lebanon’s Maronite Marada Movement thrived on the Syrian regime’s protection and was able to challenge Lebanese Maronite parties hostile to Bashar. The Marada in other words has a political, albeit contemptible, motive.
That is also the case of Lebanese Gen. Michel Aoun’s Free Patriotic Movement, except that Aoun will be the first to jump ship when Hezbollah and Bashar lose out.
There are also politicians and journalists endorsing Bashar simply for cash.
In South Lebanon’s port city of Sidon, there is the Popular Nasserite Organization, which suffices with its Nasserite credentials to account for its stance.
The organization’s icon in Cairo is former presidential candidate Hamdeen Sabahi who doesn’t hide his affinity for Bashar.
Other than those, you hardly find in Arab capitals any Bashar partisans, except perhaps the habitués of state-run Syrian TV.
They are what I would call “Speakers’ Corner forces” or “political megaphones” with no presence on the streets or in national assemblies.
One exception perhaps is in Jordan, specifically in its al-Karak city, which is home to some members of the pan-Arab Command of the Syrian Baath Party who are now lying low in view of the circumstances.
All the tiny pockets cited above are swamped by an Arab torrent sympathetic to the Syrian people.
Taking a second look at the Shiite landmass in our midst, we come up against a cohesive bloc ready to fight and die on Bashar’s side.
That’s what Hassan Nasrallah did in Qusayr and is still doing elsewhere in Syria.
Likewise, Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki is propping up the Syrian regime with arms and oil and allowing Iraqi Shiite volunteers to stream into Damascus. He is very familiar with the regime they will be fighting for.
These volunteers include politicians and clerics entrusted with the task of exonerating crimes committed by Shiites against their Sunni brothers.
A Kuwaiti parliamentarian has also openly defended and backed the interventions.
The sectarian commitment we are seeing is both unparalleled and alarming.
Even the Marjas (or highest authority on religious laws in Shiite Islam) who regularly issue fatwas and opinions have fallen silent.
They neither spoke in the revolution’s favor nor denounced the Shiites’ intervention in favor of the offender.
In my country, Saudi Arabia, the Shiite religious scholars and dignitaries kept mum on happenings in Syria.
They seem perturbed when asked, “What’s your position on the affront of the century that has seen the death so far of 100,000 Syrian Muslims?”
One cleric mouthed off: “Are we supposed to issue a statement on each occurrence? It’s a sedition and we’re distancing ourselves from it.”
My Shiite friend wanted to be amiable. He wrote to me saying, “I sympathize with the Syrian people. They deserve better than the regime killing them. But they also merit other than the Free Syrian Army.”
He probably believes he made me a big concession by saying what he did.
My answer is this: “My friend, I don’t want to be sectarian. I hate my growing sectarian penchant. But you’re not helping me.”

Friday, 14 June 2013

U.S. to arm Syria rebels, set no-fly zone near Jordan


Hot on the heels of U.S. President Barack Obama’s push into Syria, Saudi King Abdullah bin Abdulaziz is said to have cut short his private visit to Morocco to return to the kingdom overnight.
The monarch and his entourage have already left Morocco, according to Naharnet news portal.
The news follows reports of the Saudi military command ordering an “above normal defense readiness” at the kingdom’s largest air force base in Tabouk, close to the Jordan-Saudi border.
Observers associate the developments to the Syria war.
Two senior Western diplomats in Turkey told Reuters today the United States is studying setting up a limited no-fly zone in Syria close to the southern border with Jordan.
Their comments, confirmed by a third regional diplomat, came after the White House said overnight it would step up military assistance to rebels battling President Bashar al-Assad in response to proof of chemical weapons use by Assad forces.
"Washington is considering a no-fly zone to help Assad's opponents," one diplomat told Reuters. He said it would be limited "time-wise and area-wise, possibly near the Jordanian border," without giving details.
U.S. military planners, responding to a request by the White House to develop options for Syria, recommended the limited no-fly zone along the Syrian border to protect rebels and refugees inside Jordan.
The plan, according to the Wall Street Journal, would create what one official called a "no fighting zone" that would stretch up to 25 miles into Syrian territory along the Jordanian border, preventing Assad forces from launching attacks against the rebels and refugees and protecting U.S. personnel involved in distributing weapons and providing training.
Under this plan, the U.S. and its allies would enforce the zone using aircraft flown from Jordanian bases and flying inside the kingdom, according to U.S. officials.
Jordan has been inundated by a flood of refugees Jordanian and U.S. officials say is a growing threat to the kingdom, a key U.S. ally in the region.
The U.S. has already moved Patriot air defense batteries and F-16 fighter planes to Jordan, which could be integral to any no-fly zone if President Obama approves the military proposal.
Proponents of the proposal think a no-fly zone could be imposed without a UN Security Council resolution, since the U.S. would not regularly enter Syrian airspace and wouldn't hold Syrian territory.
U.S. warplanes have air-to-air missiles that could destroy Syrian planes from long ranges.
The U.S. is to supply direct military aid to the Syrian opposition for the first time, the White House announced overnight.
Ben Rhodes, spokesman for President Obama, did not give details about the military aid other than to say it would be "different in scope and scale to what we have provided before".
He said, "I can't go through an inventory of the type of assistance we are providing but suffice to say it's going to be substantively different from what we were providing."
The U.S. had warned any use of chemical weapons would cross a "red line.”
The BBC's Jim Muir in Beirut says the White House announcement is one the Syrian opposition has been pushing and praying for for months.
The Syrian opposition’s clamoring for U.S. arms peaked after thousands of guerillas from Iran’s Lebanese Hezbollah movement crossed into Syria last month to fight alongside Assad’s troops.
NATO Secretary General Anders Fogh Rasmussen welcomed Washington’s “clear” statement.
"Urgent that Syria regime should let UN investigate all reports of chemical weapons use," he said on his official Twitter feed.
Rhodes, a deputy national security adviser to President Obama, said the U.S. intelligence community believed the "Assad regime has used chemical weapons, including the nerve agent sarin, on a small scale against the opposition multiple times over the last year".
He said intelligence officials had a "high confidence" in their assessment, and also estimated that 100 to 150 people had died from chemical weapons attacks, "however, casualty data is likely incomplete".
"We have consistently said the use of chemical weapons violates international norms and crosses red lines that have existed in the international community for decades," Rhodes said.
He highlighted four instances in which the U.S. believes chemical weapons were used: on March 19 in the Aleppo suburb of Khan Al-Asal; April 13 in the Aleppo neighborhood of Sheikh Maksoud; May 14, in Qasr Abu Samra, which is north of Homs; and on May 23 in an attack in eastern Damascus.
Rhodes said President Obama had made the decision to increase assistance, including "military support", to the Supreme Military Council (SMC) and Syrian Opposition Coalition.
He did not give details of the aid, but U.S. media quoted administration officials as saying it will most likely include sending small arms and ammunition.
The New York Times quoted U.S. officials as saying Washington could provide anti-tank weapons.
Syria's rebels have been calling for both anti-tank and anti-aircraft weaponry.
The Wall Street Journal said Washington is also considering a no-fly zone inside Syria, possibly near the border with Jordan, which would protect refugees and rebels who are training there.
When asked whether Obama would back a no-fly zone over Syria, Rhodes said one would not make a "huge difference" on the ground -- but would be costly.
He said further actions would be taken "on our own timeline."
The CIA is expected to co-ordinate delivery of the military equipment and to train the rebel soldiers on how to use it.
Until now, the U.S. has limited its help to rebel forces by providing food rations and medical supplies.
Rhodes said the White House hoped the increased support would bolster the effectiveness and legitimacy of both the political and military arms of Syria's rebels, and said the U.S. was "comfortable" working with SMC chief Gen. Salim Idriss.
"It's been important to work through them while aiming to isolate some of the more extremist elements of the opposition, such as (Jabhat) al-Nusra," he said.
A senior pro-Kremlin politician in Russia -- the Damascus government’s chief ally and arms supplier -- said U.S. claims of the Assad government's use of chemical weapons were "fabricated.”
Russian President Vladimir Putin's senior foreign policy adviser Yuri Ushakov said information provided by the United States to Russia over suspected use of chemical weapons by President Assad's forces "does not look convincing.”
Obama and Putin will hold a one-on-one meeting on the sidelines of the summit of eight leading industrial nations early next week in Northern Ireland.
The White House announcement immediately shook up the ongoing debate in Washington DC over how the U.S. might provide assistance to the rebels.
Republican Senators John McCain and Lindsey Graham, who have been particularly strident in their calls for military aid, said the finding must change US policy in Syria. They called for further action, saying US credibility was on the line.
"A decision to provide lethal assistance, especially ammunition and heavy weapons, to opposition forces in Syria is long overdue, and we hope the president will take this urgently needed step," they said in a joint statement.
"But providing arms alone is not sufficient. The president must rally an international coalition to take military actions to degrade Assad's ability to use airpower and ballistic missiles and to move and resupply his forces around the battlefield by air."
House Speaker John Boehner, R-Ohio, was also pleased with the decision and had a call for further action.
"It is long past time to bring the Assad regime's bloodshed in Syria to an end," said Boehner spokesman Brendan Buck. "As President Obama examines his options, it is our hope he will properly consult with Congress before taking any action."
And House Intelligence Chairman Mike Rogers, R-Mich., released a statement saying, "I am pleased that President Obama's Administration has joined the growing international chorus declaring that the Assad regime has used chemical weapons in Syria, crossing the red line drawn by the president last August."
But Rogers doesn’t want the assistance to stop there: “As I called for in a USA Today op-ed earlier this week," Rogers said, "the United States should assist the Turks and our Arab League partners to create safe zones in Syria from which the U.S. and our allies can train, arm, and equip vetted opposition forces."

Thursday, 16 May 2013

World diplomacy is not on Assad’s wavelength



The internationally recognized representative of the Syrian people is staying away from next week’s meeting in Jordan of the 11-nation core group of the “Friends of the Syrian people.”
Jordan’s Foreign Ministry said yesterday the opposition would not be attending the planned meeting “to coordinate positions in line with the recent U.S.-Russian agreement to revive the political path to tackle the (Syria) crisis.”
Washington and Moscow have proposed a peace conference between the Syrian regime of President Bashar al-Assad and the opposition in the coming weeks to find a political solution to the country’s civil war.
The core group of the “Friends of the Syrian people” includes Egypt, France, Germany, Jordan, Italy, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Turkey, the United Arab Emirates, the UK, and the U.S.
Senior diplomats from France, the U.S., the UK, Russia and China are also planning to meet in Paris to discuss the U.S.-Russian initiative.
Expressing grave concern at the continuing escalation of violence in Syria, the UN General Assembly adopted overnight a resolution reiterating its call for rapid progress on a political transition, “which represents the best opportunity to resolve the situation […] peacefully.”
Adopted by a vote of 107 in favor to 12 against (counting Syria, Russia and China), with 59 abstentions (including Algeria, Lebanon and Sudan), the General Assembly resolution also welcomed the establishment last year of the National Coalition for Syrian Revolutionary and Opposition Forces “as effective representative interlocutors needed for a political transition.”
The State Department’s Patrick Ventrell had no explanation at yesterday’s press briefing as to why the National Coalition was staying away from the meeting in Jordan.
Q.: Patrick, Jordan has announced today that the Syrian opposition will not attend the contact group meeting that will be held next week in Jordan. Do you know why?
VENTRELL: I don’t. I’d refer you to Jordan for more details on their conference. That’s something that the Secretary looks forward to attending. But I don’t have any details on the final participation in that one way or another.
Q.: But it would be the first time that the opposition doesn’t attend such a meeting.
VENTRELL: Again, I hadn’t seen that before coming down, so I’m not aware of that information. But we’re appreciative of the Jordanians for willing to organize the meeting.
Jockeying
Editorially, Lebanese political analyst Abdelwahhab Badrakhan, writing in Arabic today for the pan-Arab daily al-Hayat, has this eye-opener on the diplomatic jockeying ahead of the peace conference proposed by the United States and Russia:
The Americans and Russians have agreed not to disagree. Despite their different perceptions and objectives, they are determined not to disagree on either Syria or nuclear Iran.
At the same time, disagreements over Russia’s aspirations in Georgia or the U.S. missile defense shield in Europe remain possible and tangible.
Regarding Syria, Moscow was allowed to sell advanced weapons to the regime to keep killing its people with no questions asked. Moscow also won – in advance – recognition of its interests in Syria and, by extension, in Lebanon plus the chance of making a comeback to Egypt via the budding Egypt-Iran partnership.
By contrast, the U.S., which won nothing in return, never sat idly on the sidelines of a crisis that matters so much to her this long.
Washington offered zero options to address the crisis, waiting instead for Benjamin Netanyahu to knock at the Kremlin door to warn against the delivery of S-300 missiles that could alter Israel’s military balance with Syria-Iran-Hezbollah.
U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry flew to Moscow May 5, seeking a new “understanding” on Syria – “understanding” because the “agreement” has to wait for the summit meeting between Barack Obama and Vladimir Putin a month from now.
Britain’s David Cameron followed Kerry to Russia, where he undertook to sponsor a multinational summit to consecrate any final U.S.-Russian agreement.
In other words, efforts are in full swing to crystallize an international consensus that would pave the way for a UN Security Council resolution under Chapter VI.
The resolution would tell the regime and the opposition to sit and negotiate on a “transitional government with full powers,” which in hindsight should have come hot on the heels of the June 2012 Geneva Declaration.
After the Geneva Declaration, Moscow kept insisting the document was the only way forward in Syria. But it never said it could secure Assad’s commitment to transfer his full executive powers to a transitional government. It kept arguing opposition and Friends of Syria calls on Assad to step down made it impossible to convince him to sign a power transfer order.
Moscow said lately it already got the names of regime negotiators, who will be led by the prime minister, but that the opposition remains disjointed and unrepresentative of all the regime’s civilian and military adversaries.
The inbred defect in Moscow’s position is its portrayal of a people’s revolution as “dissent” and the regime’s actions as “natural.”
The U.S. and Russia are now at the state where they decided, “Let us forget about Assad’s resignation and go straight to a transitional government with full powers.”
But the problem is: How would the proposed government get the full powers that Assad does not wish to hand over?
The answer would have to be a binding UN Security Council resolution under Chapter VII spelling out a timeframe and likely retributions.
Moscow has not even started considering such a course, having won enough rope from the U.S. to bury the pre-condition of Assad resigning.
Despite all the diplomatic jockeying and Washington continuing to bend over backwards, the obstacles to a Syria transition are formidable.
Russia for instance is staunchly standing by one of the regime’s own pre-conditions, which is not to touch the army or security services. This means keeping the killing machine off the negotiating table.
So how would a “transitional government with full powers” govern without the basic military and security tools of government?
For now, the “full powers” remain firmly in Assad’s hand. They need to be wrested from him. He has not been fighting to the death to surrender them readily. He will bargain over them. And he will not facilitate any solution if terms are not discussed and agreed with him.
Moreover, the relative advances of his forces on the ground lately, and seeing the international community whipping itself into a state of diplomatic frenzy to corner him, might prompt Assad to activate his spoiler role.
That would be in the traditional style of car bombings in Turkey’s border town of Reyhanli, raids on Israel by Palestinian proxies and export of the chaos and fighting to neighboring countries.

Tuesday, 30 April 2013

Obama reports Assad to Putin for cheating!

President Obama on the phone and file picture of a Syrian chemical attack victim

U.S. President Barack Obama has reported the Syrian president to his backer in the Kremlin for cheating and dabbling with chemical weapons.
That’s how I read this official White House “readout” of President Obama’s call with Russian President Vladimir Putin:
President Obama spoke by phone today [Monday] with President Putin of Russia to convey his condolences on the tragic hospital fire outside of Moscow that killed dozens last week, and to reiterate his appreciation for the close cooperation that the United States has received from Russia on the Boston marathon attack. The two Leaders discussed cooperation on counter-terrorism and security issues going forward, including with respect to the 2014 Olympics in Sochi.  President Obama and President Putin reviewed the situation in Syria, with President Obama underscoring concern over Syrian chemical weapons. The Presidents agreed to stay in close consultation and instructed Secretary [John] Kerry and Foreign Minister [Sergei] Lavrov to continue discussions on Syria. Finally, both Presidents noted that they look forward to meeting in person in June at the time of the G-8 meeting in Northern Ireland and again in September for a bilateral Summit in Russia.
Game Over
“Game Over” is a message in video games signaling that the game has ended, often due to a negative outcome.
“It’s Game Over in Syria,” Lebanese journalist, author and political analyst Samir Atallah writes today for the leading Saudi daily Asharq Alawsat.
In his words, paraphrased from Arabic:
While Barack Obama looks high and low for the red line in Syria, the Arab Mashriq seems about to fall into the netherworld.
Iraq, Jordan and Lebanon are going to rack and ruin as viable civil states. There was never a winner in wars fought by men with no colors other than the inferno colors.
Jabhat al-Nusra has set up its republic, its laws, its courts, its economy and its bakeries in all the localities it captured in and near Aleppo.
The regime in turn is trying to carve up a separate republic for itself in Homs.
For their part, the “civilians” in Istanbul keep pining for news from Ahmet Davutoglu, the learned politician who knew everything except all that has happened.
Each and every side in the conflict crossed the entire the red lines the White House preacher is hunting for.
They are all losers. And the Syria we knew is the biggest loser of them all.
What did Russia gain from Jabhat al-Nusra spreading in the north all the way to Damascus?
What did Iran benefit from most of Syria falling in the Takfiris’ hands?
What did America reap from the war, which her ambassador in Damascus started by visiting Hama, only to end up reading false reports about the whereabouts of Jihad Makdissi?
Originally, the prevailing view was the regime did not know what it had on its hand.
No one who had Syrian blood on his hands knew anything about the pothole he was jumping into. That’s why there are hands drenched in blood but no life-saving hands.
The world fought the war outwith the Security Council.
The Arabs fought it outwith their League.
The regime fought it from the start outwith any acceptable or negotiable solution.
Clock chimes are ringing out Syria’s end.
For a year now, the red line has been without benchmark or terms of reference.
The first red line was the Russian-Chinese veto.
The second red line came in Geneva with ambiguous Action Group resolutions akin to an open invitation to keep up the ruination.
The third red line considered the use of chemical weapons a game-changer – as if suggesting all other lethal and destructive weapons are green lines in the race to obliterate Syria as a nation-state.
In the end, Russia will evacuate its citizens, America will issue a travel warning to its citizens, and Iran will pull out its Revolutionary Guards, leaving Syria in shreds.
“Game Over” Iraq’s Mohammed al-Douri told the United Nations in announcing the [Saddam] regime’s fall.
It’s “Game Over” in Syria.
Press Briefing
I wrote in my post last week, “I doubt Obama would ever lift a finger against Assad.”
For those who wish to continue reading, here is how the dithering continued at yesterday’s press briefing by White House Press Secretary Jay Carney:
Q. Jay, on Syria, some questions are being raised about whether the Syrians actually used sarin on their people.  What confidence does the United States have in this evidence?  And can you characterize what exactly the evidence is in any way and what standards you’re trying to meet in terms of establishing it?
CARNEY:  We have established with varying degrees of confidence that chemical weapons were used in limited fashion in Syria and the agent is sarin, as we have said.  We have some physiological tests that are part of that collection of evidence. But there is much more to be done to verify conclusively that the red line that the President has talked about has been crossed. 
And it’s very important that we take the information that’s been gathered thus far and build upon it, because an assessment of varying degrees of confidence is not sufficient upon which to base a policy reaction, as we’ve said and as the President said in the Oval Office on Friday.
So our work continues.  We have a team -- or the United Nations has a team ready to deploy to Syria within 24 to 48 hours if Assad allows that team in and follows through on his stated commitment and interest in having this matter investigated.  And we are working with the French and the British and other allies and partners to gather more evidence.  Chain of custody is an important issue -- establishing not just that there was an incident of chemical weapons used, but how the exposure occurred, under what circumstances, who specifically was responsible, and again, the chain of custody, how the incident itself was brought about.
Q. You say physiological.  Can you be any more specific about what that evidence is and who is holding it?
CARNEY:  Physiological is tangible evidence.  And beyond that, I’m not going to be specific about it or methods and sources in terms of gathering evidence.  It is a piece in the puzzle that needs to be put together to establish the kind of verifiable, reviewable evidence that can be corroborated that we need to establish as we make decisions about policy.
(…)
Q Jay, on Syria, where exactly is that red line?
CARNEY:  The President has made clear, as he did again Friday, that the use of chemical weapons or the transfer of chemical weapons to terrorist groups would cross a red line.
What we have made clear, and we can go over it again, is that we have established with varying degrees of confidence that there have been incidents of chemical weapons used, sarin, in particular, in a limited fashion in Syria.  We are now working to build upon that evidence to increase the amount of evidence to find specifically what happened, what occurred, who was responsible and build that case, if you will.
Q. So is it the use of any amount of chemical weapons?
CARNEY:  There’s not a gradation here that I can engage in.  I can tell you that there have been, as we have assessed with varying degrees of confidence, incidents of the use of chemical weapons in a limited fashion.  But the issue here is chain of custody.  It is going on more than simply intelligence assessments.  I think our history provides us with examples of why we need to be especially assiduous when it comes to evaluating and gathering evidence in matters related to these kinds of issues.  And that's what we're doing. 
Q. But I'm trying to understand -- because I heard the President say "systematic use" on Friday -- so is it any amount? Is it a small amount?  Does it have to be a large amount to cross the red line?
CARNEY:  I think that the issue here is the use by, we believe, the regime -- because we are highly skeptical of any accusations that the opposition may have used chemical weapons -- the use by the regime of chemical weapons against the Syrian people or the transfer by the regime of some of its chemical weapons stockpile to terrorists --
Q. Any amount -- even a limited amount?
CARNEY:  I don't have an amount to give you.  Obviously, the nature of chemical weapons varies depending on the agent.  The use of chemical weapons can depend on the instance and the chain of custody.  So that's what we're investigating now.  That's what we're calling on Assad to allow the United Nations to investigate. 
So this is a very serious matter.  The President made clear this was a very serious matter.  And it is because that it is so serious that it is essential to establish a broader process of verification that will allow us then to assess whether that red line has been crossed and what the policy response will be.
Q. And on chain of custody, does it have to be something that is directed by Assad and his --
CARNEY:  We have said the use by the regime of chemical weapons would be President Assad's responsibility.  And we believe and have assessed that the chemical weapon stockpiles in Syria are under the control -- continue to be under the control of the Syrian regime, led by Bashar al-Assad. 
Again, I don't want to speculate on the incidents that we have assessed with varying degrees of confidence have occurred or may have occurred.  We are further investigating all credible information about possible use of chemical weapons in Syria and call on Assad to comply with his own request for an investigation of chemical weapons use in Syria by allowing that team in to investigate.  It's ready to go.
Q. And just one more.  How long do you think this process takes?  Are we talking like --
CARNEY:  I don't think it's possible to say necessarily, because building -- the building blocks that create the evidence necessary to make these kinds of assessment depend on what we're able to gather and it's a complex process.  Establishing the use of chemical weapons and the incidents involved and the chain of custody is not easy business, but it is essential business. 
Again, if you're as serious as the President is about this kind of transgression, if it were to occur, you need to be sure of your facts and you need to have facts that can be corroborated and that can be reviewed and that are airtight.
Q. So it could be weeks, it could be months.  It could be impossible --
CARNEY:  I don't have a timetable for you.  I would not give you a timetable.
(…)
Q    Jay, I wanted to follow on Syria, Jon’s questions about the timeline and whatnot.  Understanding, as you say, that the evidence has to be airtight -- because nobody should suggest that the administration rushed through this -- if it takes months and months to verify this or maybe a year, doesn’t that keep the door wide open for Assad to use chemical weapons?  I mean, when the President was in the briefing room here some months ago he made it seem like there will be action taken if this line is crossed.  If it drags on for months and months, it seems like the door could be open for Assad to do this again.
CARNEY:  Well, I certainly appreciate the question and I understand it.  What I won't do is speculate about how much time might be required to gather the evidence necessary to be able to assess clearly in a way that can be corroborated and reviewed whether or not this red line has been crossed.
I think all Americans would hope and expect that on a matter of this seriousness that we would be very careful in that process and would insist upon gathering all the facts, and not rushing to take action in a policy sense in reaction to assessments that are very important but are based on incomplete information.
So we need to build upon the excellent work that's been done thus far.  We call upon Assad to allow the inspection team from the United Nations to conduct the investigation that Assad himself asked for.  But we are not relying on the United Nations alone; we are working with our partners and allies as well as the Syrian opposition, very importantly, to gather more facts and evidence because this matter is so serious.
(…)
Q. I appreciate that.  Going back to Syria quickly.  The Free Syrian Army over this weekend said that Israeli Air Force jets flew over Assad’s palace and that they bombed a chemical weapons site near Damascus this weekend.  Do you have any more information about that and what the message is to Israel?
CARNEY:  I don’t have any information on that.
Q. And then, finally, if I can quickly, as we speak about Syria, can you explain -- there’s some sense that the White House is perhaps out over its skis, to use a colloquial phrase, in terms of the issue on Syria; that the language that was used before to describe this red line as this being a game-changer is now the policy doesn’t meet that place, that the words perhaps got a little bit ahead of policy right now.  If the White House wasn’t 100 percent sure when they put out the information to the Hill late last week, why right now?  Why not wait to have said something to -- created this new, complex situation?
CARNEY:  Well, I think, as you know, the President made clear the fact that there was a red line for the United States long before this report came out because he was making clear to President Assad how seriously we would view the use or transfer of Syria’s chemical weapons.  And he made that clear again on Friday when asked about this in his meeting with the King of Jordan.  And that is why we have to be so thorough in our review of and collection of evidence to prove that chemical weapons have been used.  And I think the American people would expect nothing less. 
That’s why we have made clear that while there is some evidence that leads to an assessment of varying degrees of confidence that chemical weapons have been used in a limited way in Syria, more evidence needs to be gathered to build upon the work that’s been done thus far, and that includes working with allies and partners who care deeply about this issue and have their own assessments that have been made.  It includes working, very importantly, with the Syrian opposition, and it includes urging President Assad to allow the United Nations team into Syria.
Q. So given the challenge that’s posed by the last part of your answer, which is Assad’s willingness to allow inspectors in there, if he doesn’t allow inspectors in, as appears increasingly to be the case given that hasn’t happened to this point, can the White House or can this administration ever reach a point of certitude to know that chemical weapons are being used, to mandate this reaction that the President has discussed, a game-changer? 
CARNEY:  I think that it is certainly easier if you were to have a team on the ground allowed entry by the Assad regime, but we are not waiting for that process.  We are moving forward, as we have already, to collect information and gather evidence.  We are relying and working with the Syrian opposition, as well as our allies and partners in that effort.  And that effort will continue. 
But there is no question that this not easy business and it needs to be thorough, and we need to establish the highest possible level of confidence in the assessments that we make.  And that's why we’re assembling the facts in the way that we are.
Q. Thank you, Jay.