Pages

Showing posts with label Gaza Strip. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Gaza Strip. Show all posts

Thursday, 22 November 2012

Gaza crisis: The winners and losers


Hamas' Khaled Meshaal (top) and Hillary Clinton with Amr (center), Abbas (left) and Netanyahu 
Political analysts and commentators in today’s Arab press concentrate on naming winners and losers in the eight-day clash between Israel and the Islamist Hamas movement that runs the Gaza Strip.
An Egypt-brokered ceasefire between the two sides, which went into effect overnight, appears to be holding.
Egyptian Foreign Minister Kamel Amr announced the truce in Cairo Wednesday evening in the presence of U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton who had taken part in the negotiations, first in Jerusalem and Ramallah and later in Cairo.
Five Israelis and 162 Palestinians were killed in the flare-up. Health authorities in Gaza say the dead Palestinians included 42 children, 11 women and 18 elderly. They also put the number of injured at 1,222, more than half of them women and children.
Under the deal (see below), Israel agreed to end all hostilities and targeted killings, while all Palestinian factions undertook to stop firing rockets into Israel and staging border attacks. Israel must also begin talks about opening Gaza's border crossings and easing restrictions on the movement of people and goods.
Following is the verbatim English text of the deal as released by Egypt:
Understanding Regarding Ceasefire in Gaza Strip
1. a. Israel shall stop all hostilities from the Gaza Strip land, sea and air including incursions and targeting of individuals.
b. All Palestinian factions shall stop all hostilities from the Gaza Strip against Israel, including rocket attacks and all attacks along the border.
c. Opening the crossings and facilitating the movement of people and transfer of goods, and refraining from restricting residents' free movements, and targeting residents in border areas and procedures of implementation shall be dealt with after 24 hours from the start of the ceasefire.
d. Other matters as may be requested shall be addressed.
2. Implementation Mechanism:
a. Setting up the zero hour for the Ceasefire Understanding to enter into effect.
b. Egypt shall receive assurances from each party that the party commits to what was agreed upon.
c. Each party shall commit itself not to perform any acts that would breach this understanding. In case of any observations, Egypt -- as the sponsor of this understanding -- shall be informed to follow up.
An article by Ali Derbaj on Hezbollah’s Almanar portal features three learned opinions on the denouement of the Gaza crisis:
-- Strategy consultant Anis Naccache, a Lebanese militant who spent 10 years in a French jail and now lives between Beirut and Tehran, says the eight days of violence exposed serious flaws in Israel’s “Iron Dome” missile interceptor. This means the whole of Mandatory Palestine is from this day forward “in the gunsight of the Resistance camp’s missiles.”
-- Hilal Khashan, a leading Palestinian-American scholar of the Middle East and a professor of political science at the American University of Beirut, believes “Iran proved to be a key player in the Gaza battle. Her Fajr-5 missile was the star of the face-off.”
-- Retired Gen. Elias Hanna names Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas as the primary loser and Egypt as the most embarrassed. Abbas was shown to be “a figurehead. The real combat and effective negotiation capabilities will be shifting to Gaza.”
Abdelbari Atwan, publisher/editor of the London-based daily al-Quds al-Arabi, says, “I was greatly disappointed when I did not find the lifting of the Gaza siege one of the main provisions of the truce agreement announced in Cairo.”
But the following heartens Atwan:
-- Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu proved to be a political novice. Instead of Gazans fleeing en masse as he expected, they stood their ground and fought him back.
-- West Bankers defied the “state of paralysis” embraced by the Palestinian Authority and marched in solidarity with their kinsfolk in the Strip.
-- New life was breathed into the Palestine Question, which had been eclipsed by the Arab Spring.
-- The restart of attacks in the heart of Tel Aviv and maybe elsewhere in Israel.
-- Restoration of the “balance of terror” between Israel and the Palestinian people.
Walid Abi-Mershed, writing for the leading Saudi daily Asharq Alawsat, says, “It is true the latest Israeli blitz on Gaza was another episode in the lopsided confrontation between an eye and an awl. What changed is that Israel is no more able of confining the conflict to a strip of land or to some adjoining kilometers. The ‘eye versus an awl’ war has now transformed into a missiles war on the Tel-Aviv front.”
Rajeh el-Khoury, in his daily column for the independent Beirut daily an-Nahar, believes “the ceasefire agreement secured advantages to all the parties concerned except the Palestinian Authority.”
Proof is that “America gained the commitment of the Muslim Brotherhood’s Egypt to the existing [Camp David] agreements and to Egypt’s assigned task as appeaser; Egypt recouped its regional role; Israel walked away with the destruction of what remains of Gaza and consolidated ties with Egypt as the guarantor of calm; and Hamas prevailed as the Palestinian Authority’s domineering partner. As usual, Palestine ended the biggest loser.”
Jordan’s one-time information minister Saleh Qallab, writing for Saudi Asharq Alawsat, suggests “the major and most serious gain bagged by Israel is telling the West and the United States on the eve of Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas’ trip to New York to address the UN General Assembly and ask for an upgrade of the Palestinians’ status there to a non-member state: The Hamas missiles fired on Israeli townships and cities testify that creation of a Palestinian state in Gaza, on the West Bank or in both areas would be tantamount to placing a primed time-bomb on Israel’s doorstep.”

Tuesday, 20 November 2012

Iran’s missiles: With or against the Arabs?


Egypt-brokered talks to end a week of Israeli-Hamas violence continue.
U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton is heading to the region and the UN chief has once again appealed from Cairo for an immediate ceasefire.
Grieving Gazans were today burying civilians killed in ongoing Israeli airstrikes, and barrages of rockets from Gaza sent terrified Israelis scurrying to take cover.
The conflict began last Wednesday when Israel killed a top Hamas military commander, saying it wanted to end rocket attacks on its soil.
More than 110 Palestinians and three Israelis have been killed so far.
Mohammed al-Rumaihi, a Kuwaiti professor of political sociology who has published more than 20 books on social and cultural change in the Gulf and Arab world, wonders in a news analysis for the Saudi daily Asharq Alawsat whether the Iranian missiles supplied to Hamas in Gaza were meant to be “with or against the Arabs.”
He writes:
Hamas lobbed rockets into Israeli cities, sparking off euphoria on Arab streets. For the first time, missiles were aimed at areas in Israel where the alarm siren was never heard before. Israel’s reach is not what it used to be – it can no more kill Arabs on a whim.
The missiles flying from Gaza raised the Islamic Republic of Iran’s fame as their exclusive designer and manufacturer. And that’s exactly what the Islamic Republic is after – winning the Arab street, which is by nature emotive and easily enraptured by anyone trying to punish Israel for disgraceful transgressions.
But there are Iranian missiles and bombs being used to kill other Arabs in Syrian villages, towns and cities. No one has yet explained why Iran’s military hardware is used to defend some Arabs in one place and kill other Arabs somewhere else at the same time without hurting their enemy.
Iran basically plays to win. She wins loads when Arab public opinion deems her to the defender of downtrodden Palestinians, who are used as fodder for Israel’s killing machine.
Iran helps kill Syrians trying to break free from the alliance she champions. At the same time, Iran’s cat’s-paw in Lebanon, Hezbollah, remains a Gaza bystander, saving its huge missile arsenal to fight Lebanese Arabs.
The play is truly surreal. The play’s producer says the weapons should only be used when they serve their provider’s interests, i.e. Iran.
Israel’s human and material losses from Iranian rockets in the weeklong violence are infinitesimal compared to the losses inflicted on the Syrian people.
The Gaza conflict was also timed to be unkind to the new regime in Egypt. Whoever chose to pull the trigger meant to put Egypt on the spot by forcing it to choose between backing Palestinians on the ground or doing nothing, as Mubarak’s Egypt would have done.
Cairo, it seems, chose to play the game. It sent its prime minister for a few hours to Gaza and followed up with plenty of verbiage about solidarity, support and brotherhood. But the end result is the same – an attempt to mediate between the two protagonists, as Hosni Mubarak used to do.
The Arab League was probably more loud-mouthed this time, but nothing more.
The Gaza conflict achieved the following:
  • It allowed some people to extol the virtues of Iran’s weapons technology, especially after last month’s launch by Hezbollah of an Iranian-made drone over Israel, which was shot down by Israeli forces.
  • It revived talk of Iran being the indisputable backer of Palestinians.
  • It left in the shade a key accomplishment by the Syrian people who saw their opposition groups unite in a coalition in Doha and go on to win unprecedented international recognition.
  • It boosted Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s reelection chances.

Monday, 19 November 2012

Why Morsi is the fitting Israel-Hamas pacifier

Clockwise from L.: Gaza victims, Egypt's Morsi and Iran's Supreme Leader

International efforts to wrest a cease-fire from Israel and the Hamas-ruled Gaza Strip are gathering momentum.
The two sides are putting forth widely divergent demands to halt five days of violence. The violence saw Israel launch ceaseless air, tank and warship strikes on the Strip and Hamas fire a stream of rockets into Israel, including into the Tel Aviv and Jerusalem areas.
By this writing, 84 Palestinians, most of them civilians, have been killed and 720 have been wounded. Three Israeli civilians have died from Hamas rocket fire and a dozen have been wounded.
President Barack Obama said he was in touch with players across the region in hopes of halting the fighting. While defending Israel's right to defend itself against the rocket fire, he also warned of the risks Israel would take if it were to expand its air assault into a ground war.
UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon said Sunday afternoon he would head to the region and "appeal personally for ending the violence." French Foreign Minister Laurent Fabius met with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu earlier in the day, and an Israeli representative was in Egypt earlier in an attempt to negotiate a peaceful settlement.
Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu is expected to pay a snap visit to Gaza as part of an Arab League delegation to express support and solidarity.
Morocco’s King Mohammed VI has meantime ordered the immediate setting up of a Moroccan field hospital in the Gaza Strip.
The hospital will comprise specialized medical units of the Royal Moroccan Armed Forces, as well as Moroccan civilian physicians and paramedics. The multidisciplinary medical-surgical hospital will reinforce existing medical facilities there.
According to a senior State Department official, Egypt has an important leadership role to play in brokering a cessation of the violence between Hamas and Israel.
Egypt, the official said, “has the relationships in Gaza; Prime Minister Qandil travelled there yesterday and had the opportunity to meet with (Ismail) Haniyeh, and other leaders in Hamas. So we believe that they have the stature, the credibility, and the relationships to be able to persuade Hamas and its allies to stop… There are other actors involved like the Turks and the Qataris and others who also have a role to play. But Egypt’s role is absolutely pivotal.”
Ghassan Charbel, editor-in-chief of pan-Arab daily al-Hayat, believes post-Mubarak Egypt under President Mohamed Morsi, a former leader of the Muslim Brotherhood, “simply can’t cut loose from Gaza’s destiny.”
Charbel explains in a leader comment penned in Arabic:
Other than the rationales of geographic contiguity, security, stability and role, Egypt now has a regime begotten by the revolution and entrusted to the Muslim Brothers by the ballot box.
Consequently, Hamas neither can nor wishes to deal with Morsi’s Egypt the way it dealt with Egypt under Hosni Mubarak.
Israel’s onslaught on Gaza showed the Arab Spring did not let the Palestinian cause fall from its list of priorities. The offensive gave Arab Spring countries the chance to reiterate that injustice to the Palestinians is in their hearts and minds and will have pride of place in their priorities.
The region has changed. More exactly, it is changing.
Despite lingering uncertainties, apprehensions and machinations, the Arab Spring is probably the most important regional event since the 1979 Iranian Revolution.
From this perspective, let’s ponder conditions in the two countries that initiated the Axis of Resistance.
Iran is buckling under the weight of economic sanctions. Her role in the region is melting away after colliding with the Arab Spring, specifically in Syria. Her nuclear program is closely monitored by Western powers.
Syria, the Arab partner in the Axis of Resistance, sees her regime loosing control on the ground and becoming an Arab, Islamic and international pariah.
The Hamas movement, whose leadership resided in Syria, was the Sunnite link in the Axis of Resistance grouping Iran, Syria and Hezbollah. It was also the golden link in the chain because it introduced the Axis’ missiles and modus operandi to the heart of Palestinian territory.
Consisting of Hamas and Islamic Jihad, the Palestinian offshoot of the Axis of Resistance played a key role over the past two 20-odd years. Hamas and Islamic Jihad helped exasperate hopes pinned on the Oslo Accords, militarize the Second Intifada, and undermine the successive clout and authority of Yasser Arafat and Mahmoud Abbas. Their suicide attacks shored up Israeli hardliners.
With the two Palestinian groups tagging along, Iran and Syria were able to gain veto power on any idea of Palestinian-Israeli or Arab-Israeli peace.
The Arab Spring was a bolt from the blue for Syria. But it allowed Hamas leaders residing in Damascus to nose out the Arab Spring’s Muslim Brotherhood scent.
Although Hamas initially refused to take a stand for or against the Syrian uprising, it was against the grain of its political chief Khaled Meshaal to follow in Hezbollah’s suit and take orders from Iran’s Supreme Leader. Hamas consequently elected to emigrate from Damascus and align itself with the Muslim Brotherhood Supreme Guide based in Egypt.
Israel’s blitz on Gaza came on the heels of such momentous changes. Israeli warplanes pummeled the Strip while Hamas and Islamic Jihad hit back with rockets targeting Tel Aviv and Jerusalem.
Remarkably, Hamas hastened to tell everyone trying to broker de-escalation that the address for negotiations is Egypt.
Morsi’s telephone hasn’t stopped ringing. Morsi has no choice but to seek a quick return to calm and normalcy. He cannot see Hamas crushed in Gaza. And he cannot gamble away Egypt’s international ties and financial aid either. He would not risk the Brotherhood’s credentials for running Egypt. 

Saturday, 17 November 2012

Hezbollah rolls out missiles supply bridge to Gaza


Journalist Hassan Aleeq of al-Akhbar (center)

An “adequate supply” of long-range missiles has found its way to the embattled Gaza Strip “in the past few hours,” according to a news report published in Beirut this morning.
The report penned by journalist Hassan Aleeq makes the front-page of al-Akhbar.
The newspaper speaks for the so-called “Axis of Resistance” grouping Syria, Iran and Hezbollah.
Hezbollah’s own al-Manar portal reproduces the report with a footnote saying, “Al-Manar is not responsible for the wording and content of the article, which expresses the point of view of the author.”
“During the past hours,” Aleeq writes, “a state of alert was declared in the ranks of Hezbollah and Iran’s Revolutionary Guards.
“Obviously, the state of alert does not cover all their military units, whose state of preparedness has been raised in anticipation of any masked Israeli folly.
“What was placed on red alert, however, are those (units) experienced in smuggling arms from Syria, Lebanon, Iran, Sudan, (and elsewhere) to Egypt (specifically Sinai) and on to the Gaza Strip.
“That’s the well-known route, but there are other ways of delivering what should be placed in the hands of the Resistance in Gaza.”
Aleeq says the focus now is on channeling a large number of long-range missiles to Hamas-ruled Gaza.
Accordingly, “an adequate number of available long-range missiles” have already reached the Gaza Strip.
“Those familiar with the modus operandi of the Resistance in Lebanon and Palestine,” writes Aleeq, “are emphatic supply lines won’t stop either during the aggression or after its cessation.
“…Ultimately, [Hezbollah] in Lebanon and its backers are aware the war raging in Gaza these days is aimed against it as well. That’s why [Hezbollah] will spare no effort to convey all available weapons where they need to reach.”
Israel bombarded the Gaza Strip with nearly 200 airstrikes early Saturday, widening a blistering assault on militant rocket operations.
The new attacks followed Gaza’s unprecedented rocket strikes aimed at Tel Aviv and Jerusalem.
In the latest round of the conflict – triggered by Israel’s assassination of Hamas’ military chief, Ahmed al-Jaabari, on Wednesday -- the Gazans have used a rocket that can strike at Israel's heartland. This is the Fajr-5, developed by Iran and also supplied to Hezbollah. It has a range of up to 75 kilometers, which means it can hit central Israel.
By mid-day Saturday, 39 Palestinians including 13 civilians and three Israeli civilians have been killed since the Israeli operation began.