Pages

Showing posts with label Netanyahu. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Netanyahu. Show all posts

Friday, 29 November 2013

Fourth major U.S.-Israel crisis looming


Clockwise from top R.: Roger Stone's book jacket and Ben-Gurion with Presidents Kennedy and Eisenhower

Will U.S.-Israel relations fray over Iran?
It looks like they will, according to veteran Lebanese journalist Selim Nassar writing for pan-Arab daily al-Hayat the week preceding the world powers’ nuclear deal with the Islamic Republic.
Nassar expected last Sunday’s agreement in Geneva between the 5+1 world powers and Iran to mark the fourth hiccup of note in the 65-year-old “special relationship” between the United States and Israel.
The first U.S.-Israel tiff occurred under President Dwight D. Eisenhower, who compelled the Israelis to evacuate the Sinai Peninsula following the 1956 Suez War.
Eisenhower wrote to Israeli Prime Minister David Ben-Gurion on November 7, 1956 saying:
Dear Mr. Prime Minister:
As you know, the General Assembly of the United Nations has arranged a cease-fire in Egypt to which Egypt, France, the United Kingdom and Israel have agreed. There is being dispatched to Egypt a United Nations force in accordance with pertinent resolutions of the General Assembly. That body has urged that all other foreign forces be withdrawn from Egyptian territory, and specifically, that Israeli forces be withdrawn to the General Armistice line. The resolution covering the cease-fire and withdrawal was introduced by the United States and received the overwhelming vote of the Assembly.
Statements attributed to your Government to the effect that Israel does not intend to withdraw from Egyptian territory, as requested by the United Nations, have been called to my attention. I must say frankly, Mr. Prime Minister, that the United States views these reports, if true, with deep concern. Any such decision by the Government of Israel would seriously undermine the urgent efforts being made by the United Nations to restore peace in the Middle East, and could not but bring about the condemnation of Israel as a violator of the principles as well as the directives of the United Nations.
It is our belief that as a matter of highest priority peace should be restored and foreign troops, except for United Nations forces, withdrawn from Egypt, after which new and energetic steps should be undertaken within the framework of the United Nations to solve the basic problems, which have given rise to the present difficulty. The United States has tabled in the General Assembly two resolutions designed to accomplish the latter purposes, and hopes that they will be acted upon favorably as soon as the present emergency has been dealt with.
I need not assure you of the deep interest, which the United States has in your country, nor recall the various elements of our policy of support to Israel in so many ways. It is in this context that I urge you to comply with the resolutions of the United Nations General Assembly dealing with the current crisis and to make your decision known immediately. It would be a matter of the greatest regret to all my countrymen if Israeli policy on a matter of such grave concern to the world should in any way impair the friendly cooperation between our two countries.
With best wishes,
Sincerely,
Dwight D. Eisenhower
The second full-blown crisis between the U.S. and Israel started after President John F. Kennedy took office in 1961.
This is how Israel’s Jerusalem Post described Kennedy’s actions:
The clash began in 1960, when the outgoing Eisenhower administration sought an explanation for the mysterious construction near Dimona. It was told that this top-secret activity in the middle of the desert was a harmless textile plant, and no, it could not come and visit. Classified spy photos were then published on the front page of The New York Times (yes, the CIA spied on the Jewish state, with or without forged passports).
When President Kennedy took office in 1961, the disagreement became a full-blown crisis. Like Obama, Kennedy was not inherently hostile, but he did not have a special sympathy for the Jewish people. His advisers urged continuous pressure, assuming that Israel would have no choice but to accept U.S. demands. Every high-level meeting or communication repeated the demand for inspection of Dimona. One form of pressure was to deny Ben-Gurion an invitation to the White House – his May 1961 meeting with Kennedy was a low-key affair at the Waldorf Astoria Hotel in New York, and was dominated by this issue.
… If the U.S. government were to impose tax restrictions, the costs would have been very high. Ben-Gurion avoided saying no by dancing around them for two years.
Finally, Kennedy had enough, and in a personal letter dated May 18, 1963, the president warned that unless American inspectors were allowed into Dimona (meaning the end of any military activities), Israel would find itself totally isolated.
Nassar quotes Ben-Gurion as having told aides after a stormy meeting with Kennedy: “It’s difficult to put up with a Catholic president at the White House.”
But then fate intervened and Kennedy was assassinated on November 22, 1963. The Israelis were off the hook. Not one of Kennedy’s successors ever even attempted to confront (or even acknowledge) Israel’s nuclear arsenal.
Fifty years after his death, a scant 25% of Americans believe the official version of Kennedy’s death, according to a recent poll.
The government’s story, promulgated by the Warren Commission — an investigatory body created a week after the assassination — said that a lone gunman, Lee Harvey Oswald, fired three shots, two of which fatally struck Kennedy.
Oswald acted alone, the Warren Commission said, and so did Jack Ruby, the man who shot and killed Oswald two days later.
In the decades since, advances in criminal forensics and technology have upheld some of the Warren Commission’s findings and cast doubt on others.
In his new book – “The Man Who Killed Kennedy: The Case Against LBJ” -- Roger Stone, the sharp-dressed, rightwing political operative who is no fan of any Democrat and who worked on the Nixon, Reagan and George H.W. Bush presidential campaigns, has it in for Lyndon Johnson.
Stone accuses Johnson of responsibility for nine murders, including the greatest crime of the 20th century, the assassination of John F. Kennedy.
Some J.F.K. conspiracy theories blame the mafia, some blame the CIA and some blame the far right or the far left. Stone’s theory wraps together all those ideas and puts Johnson upfront as the ringmaster. “He’s the lynchpin of a conspiracy involving others,” Stone said.
His theory is buttressed with innuendo. Stone said Nixon once told him that both he and Johnson badly wanted the presidency but that, unlike Johnson, “I wasn’t willing to kill for it.”
Nassar goes on to write, “Johnson’s pro-Israel policies made possible Israel’s occupation of territory in three Arab countries during the 1967 war.”
The third bilateral spat came after the October 1973 Arab-Israeli war.
Nassar recalls Nixon and his secretary of state, Henry Kissinger, were received in Damascus by then Syrian President Hafez Assad on June 16, 1974.
Assad, Nassar reports, started explaining why he accepted UNSC Resolutions 242 and 338 and his willingness to recognize Israel within its pre-June 1967 borders.
Nassar suggests Kissinger interrupted the Nixon-Assad discourse under the pretext of time pressure.
Nassar interviewed Nixon in New York in June 1983, when the former president dwelt on the Watergate scandal, suggesting the exclusive reports by Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein for the Washington Post on the break-in at the Watergate office complex in Washington had more to do with Middle East politics than U.S. political affairs.
Some 40 years after Watergate, Nassar remarks, former FBI agent Mark Felt revealed himself as the Watergate whistleblower but said nothing about Convicted American spy for Israel Jonathan Pollard who this month entered the 29th year of a life sentence in a U.S. prison.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is one of the most prominent critics of this week’s U.S. deal with Iran. While President Barack Obama calls the agreement a breakthrough, Netanyahu calls it a "historic mistake." And neither leader fully trusts the other.
Is a fourth major U.S.-Israel crisis on the cards?

Tuesday, 26 November 2013

Arabs & Israel feel shortchanged by ‘Great Satan’


America's Obama Obama and Iran's Rouhani (from algemeiner.com)

Led by Saudi Arabia, Arab governments are dumbstruck by Iran’s nuclear deal with world powers and the Islamic Republic’s acceptance on the global stage.
Not so Israel, which calls the deal a “mistake,” and not so the overwhelming majority of political analysts and commentators in the Arab media.
Fahmi Howeidi, dean of these Arab public opinion-shapers, concludes his think piece today for Aljazeera TV news portal with a sentence saying: “The long and short of the new balance of power in the Arab world is this: Iran tops the list of winners but there is no mention of the Arabs anywhere.”
Tariq Alhomayed, writing today for Asharq Alawsat, the Saudi newspaper of records of which he was editor-in-chief, believes “the deal with Iran is more treacherous than 9/11.”
U.S. President Barack Obama overnight defended the deal between Iran and world powers on Tehran's nuclear program.
The six-month interim deal struck in Geneva on Sunday saw Iran agree to curb some of its nuclear activities in return for sanctions relief.
The accord has been generally welcomed but Israel's prime minister called it "a historic mistake".
The West has long suspected Iran's uranium enrichment program is geared towards making a weapon, but Tehran insists it only wants nuclear energy.
The UN, U.S. and European Union had imposed a raft of sanctions on Tehran.
"Huge challenges remain, but we cannot close the door on diplomacy, and we cannot rule out peaceful solutions to the world's problems," the BBC quoted Obama as saying during an event in San Francisco.
"We cannot commit ourselves to an endless cycle of violence, and tough talk and bluster may be the easy thing to do politically, but it's not the right thing for our security."
Earlier, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu announced an Israeli team led by national security adviser Yossi Cohen would travel to Washington for talks on the deal.
"This accord must bring about one outcome: the dismantling of Iran's military nuclear capability," he said.
Israel has not ruled out taking military action to stop Iran developing the capability of a nuclear bomb.
Saudi Arabia -- Iran's regional counterweight -- cautiously welcomed the deal yesterday.
Under the deal which will last six months, Iran would receive some $7bn in "limited, temporary, targeted, and reversible [sanctions] relief" while a permanent agreement is sought.
Key points of the deal include:
  • Iran will stop enriching uranium beyond 5% and "neutralize" its stockpile of uranium enriched beyond this point
  • Iran will give greater access to inspectors including daily access at Natanz and Fordo -- two of Iran’s key nuclear sites
  • There will be no further development of the Arak plant, which it is believed could produce plutonium
  • In return, there will be no new nuclear-related sanctions for six months if Iran sticks by the accord
  • Some sanctions will be suspended on trading in gold and precious metals, on Iran's car-making sector and its petrochemical exports
  • Frozen oil sale assets will be transferred in installments, bringing in some $4.2bn of extra revenue.
Howeidi, in his piece today for Aljazeera quotes unnamed Iranian experts as telling him:
  • The deal recognizes Iran as a regional nuclear power with the right to continue its uranium enrichment program for peaceful purposes
  • The Iranians and Americans rushed the deal through to sidestep adverse pressure by Israel, France and some Gulf Arab lobbyists
  • The Iranian-American understandings go beyond the nuclear program and the easing of economic sanctions. “The most important understanding is over Iran’s participation in the fight against terrorism in Syria, Iraq, Lebanon and Afghanistan”
  • The deal allows Iran to receive some $7 billion in sanctions relief; about $1.5 billion of the frozen assets were promptly released to Tehran “by Asian banks in South Korea, Malaysia and Indonesia as early as last Sunday morning”
  • Shell, which was complying with the sanctions, was the first oil major to resume work in Iran.
Howeidi sums up the most important features of the agreement between the 5+1 world powers and Iran as follows:
  1. It seems a new axis is taking shape in the region comprising Iran and Russia, the two countries that played a key role in aborting an American military strike against Syria.
  2. The U.S. will henceforth “rely on Iran and Turkey to keep the peace in the region now that Egypt has lost its standing in the Arab world.” Iran is on the ground in Syria, Iraq and Lebanon and to some degree in Yemen, where it is supporting the Houthis. Turkey on the other hand has its role in Syria, Iraq and the Caucasus in Central Asia. Ankara also has its strong economic ties with many Arab countries.
  3. There are still question marks over a sectarian war between the Sunnis and Shiites in the Arab world, over Iran’s support of the Islamic movements in Palestine and Lebanon and over future links between Cairo and Tehran.
  4. Israel is in a win-win situation. Syria’s chemical weapons are being buried and checks on Iran’s nuclear ambitions are being put in place.
  5. Iran’s clout in the Gulf, Syria, Iraq and Lebanon is on the ascendancy. The Gulf, which usually banks on the U.S. is now less prone to challenge Iran. That’s particularly true of Saudi Arabia, which lost its gamble on America’s air strike on Syrian regime forces and on mobilizing Sunni forces against Tehran.
  6. “The long and short of the new balance of power in the Arab world is this: Iran tops the list of winners but there is no mention of the Arabs anywhere.”
In the view of Saudi journalist Tariq Alhomayed, “fallouts of the deal on the region – specifically on Saudi Arabia and its Gulf Arab partners – will prove more treacherous than the consequences of the 9/11 terrorist outrage that pummeled the United States in 2001.
“I am not dramatizing. It is not so because the Obama Administration sold the region down the river or that the administration turned its back on its historic partnership with Gulfite Arabs.
Many forget that America betrayed Israel, her sacred cow in the region.
Alhomayed says Iran’s chief objective since the days of the late Shah Mohammad Reza Pahlevi was to become the “region’s policeman.”
The Islamic Republic will eventually rid itself of all economic sanctions and achieve its primary objective of creating nuclear weapons “much as India and Pakistan did under Bill Clinton, another Democratic Party president.” 

Tuesday, 2 July 2013

Kerry: Geneva-2 on Syria in September possibly


Kerry trying a shawarma sandwich at an eatery in al-Bireh...
... followed by Nabulsi kenafeh (Photos are by AFP)

Geneva-2 on Syria – inshallah
Israel-Palestine peace talks – in a bit
Shawarma – yummy
U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry said today both the U.S. and Russia are seriously committed to having an international conference on Syria and setting up a transitional government to end the bloodshed.
But he acknowledged the conference might not be possible until August or later.
Kerry spoke outside the U.S. Embassy in Brunei after a 90-minute-plus meeting with Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov on the sidelines of an Asian security summit.
The proposed conference, which Kerry and Lavrov had planned for end-May, is known as "Geneva-2" because it follows a Syria meeting in the Swiss city in June 2012.
The secretary of state flew in for the ASEAN summit in Bandar Seri Begawan, Brunei, after failing to achieve a breakthrough in setting up peace talks between Israeli and Palestinian leaders despite an intense four-day round of shuttle diplomacy. Yet he left Tel Aviv at the weekend with a lot of optimism and promised that he is close to progress.
He met separately a total of three times with Benyamin Netanyahu and Mahmoud Abbas, spending a total of 13 hours talking to the Israeli prime minister and around seven to the Palestinian president.
Following one of his meetings with Abbas at the latter’s office in Ramallah, Kerry wandered the streets of the central West Bank city of al-Bireh, where he ate a shawarma sandwich and Nabulsi kenafeh at a local eatery.
Following are his remarks after meeting with Lavrov in Brunei today:
Hi, everybody. I thought the meeting I had with Secretary Lavrov merited saying a few words because I think it was constructive and very useful, and I think we both agreed with that. We discussed a wide range of issues, but we obviously focused mostly on the issue of Syria.
I did raise the issue of, obviously, [National Security Agency leaker Edward] Snowden, but that is not his portfolio. It’s being handled – nor is it mine directly because it’s being handled within the Justice Department. So it is fair to say that we didn’t discuss any substantive progress, but I certainly raised, from our point of view, how it fits within the context of our relationship. But again, not his portfolio, and so it wasn’t discussed in a way that he would be able to take any action on it, though I hope he will communicate the views that I expressed.
On Syria, we had a very in-depth conversation, and I thought it was important to note that Foreign Minister Lavrov believes, as I do, and as I think President Obama and President Putin believe, that there are two countries that can have the most significant difference on this question, and they are Russia and the United States. We agreed that we are both serious, more than serious – committed to the Geneva process, and we both agreed that our countries have an ability to be able to make a difference if we can pull together in that effort.
We made progress in talking through and building on some of the issues that were discussed in Geneva on June 25th by our Under Secretary Wendy Sherman and by their deputy, Mr. Bogdanov, as well as Lakhdar Brahimi. We narrowed down some of the options with respect to the potential of that conference. We both agreed that that conference should happen sooner rather than later, though we have a 2+2 meeting between Russia and the United States in July, and obviously August is very difficult for Europeans and for others, so it may be somewhere thereafter, but that’s being talked about.
What is clear to me coming out of this meeting and what we both wanted to really ascertain from each other is the level of seriousness and the capacity to be able to do this. Geneva relies on – the next Geneva relies on the work of the first Geneva, which calls for a transitional government with a neutral environment, by mutual consent, with the full transfer of power.
Whether the Assad regime is doing better or whether the opposition is doing better is frankly not determinative of that outcome because the outcome requires a transition government. And that’s why it is valuable to try to get to Geneva.
So we will continue to push. There are still things that have to be worked out over the course of these next days, but Foreign Minister Lavrov and I felt that this meeting was a very useful meeting. It was constructive, it was conducted in a constructive way, and our objective remains the same; that is, to recognize the notion that there really isn’t a military victory per se in Syria that keeps Syria as a country, and number two that we have an obligation to try to work towards a peaceful resolution because a peaceful settlement is the best way to save the state of Syria and to minimize the destruction. That commitment remains a solid one between both of us.
So I’m not going to take questions now because I’ve got a group of people waiting and we have a very, very tight schedule to move out of here.

Tuesday, 14 May 2013

Putin-Netanyahu: It's not just the missiles, stupid

Putin and Netanyahu in Jerusalem last year and an AP file photo of the Russian S-300

The S-300 air defense system Netanyahu is urging Putin not to sell to Syria is the “ultimate” in protection, says top Israeli missile expert Uzi Rubin. But it’s still only a part of the wider problem of Russia’s unwavering support for Assad

By Mitch Ginsburg, writing today for The Times of Israel
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, only just back from China, was back overseas on Tuesday, meeting with President Vladimir Putin to ensure –- or more accurately to plead — that Russia refrain from sending Syria four S-300 batteries, a $900-million, long-range aerial defense system that, Israeli experts say, would change the calculus of Israeli and U.S. involvement in Syria.
Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov struck a defiant tone in advance of the meeting. “Russia is not planning to sell,” he told reporters in Warsaw, without specifying which systems he was referring to. “Russia already sold them a long time ago. It has signed the contracts and is completing deliveries, in line with the agreed contracts, of equipment that is anti-aircraft technology.”
Russian state TV was even more explicit. “After the S-300s are put into service, a repeat of the Libyan scenario — the imposition of a no-fly zone over the country — would be extremely difficult,” the Wall Street Journal reported (Russia news channel) Vesti-24 as saying.
Israeli experts largely agree with this assessment. The S-300, which can intercept fighter jets and cruise missiles, “is the ultimate system,” said Uzi Rubin, the former head of missile defense at Israel’s Defense Ministry and a senior researcher at the Begin Sadat Center for Strategic Studies. “It covers enormous surfaces and is so potent that when the Cypriots bought the system the Turks threatened them with war because it endangered Turkish aircraft flying over Turkey.”
Nonetheless, Rubin said, it is the fact of Russian unstinting involvement on Bashar Assad’s behalf in Syria, more than the precise nature of that role, which dictates the course of events.
A review of Assad’s air defenses, their capacity and their performance in recent years — including after a 2007 upgrade — underlines the importance of the S-300 amid what thus far has been unwavering Russian support.
In 1967 Israel destroyed Syria’s air force on the first day of the war. By 1973 the situation had changed. The Russian SA-6 system downed more than 20 IAF planes over Syria.
Yet air defense systems, Rubin explained, are a lot like locks. Some are old and feeble. They can be cut with a pair of pliers and tossed aside. Some are familiar. An experienced thief knows how to extract the combination with relative ease. And some are state-of-the-art and keep all but the best at bay.
By 1982, Israel, unbeknown to Syria, had cracked the combination to Russian air defense. On June 9, the fourth day of the Lebanon War, after Syria had moved 19 SA-6 surface-to-air missile batteries southwest into Lebanon’s Bekaa Valley in order to protect PLO forces there, Israel launched an attack. Using a combination of radar-jamming electronic warfare, radiation-seeking missiles and, according to international reports, early unmanned aircraft, the IAF destroyed 17 of the 19 batteries and downed 29 Syrian jets without suffering any losses of its own.
“That’s how it is,” said Rubin. “Air defense is always a game of cops and robbers, and once you know a system for some time, you get to know its strong points and its weak points.”
In September 2007, Israel reportedly exploited its technological advances to blind Syrian air defenses and strike and destroy Syria’s plutonium reactor in the far northeast of the country.
Subsequently, Syria set out to further modernize its aging defenses. That same year, Assad signed contracts with Russia for the Pantsir-S1 mobile air defense units. Prime minister Ehud Olmert reportedly met with then Prime Minister Putin to bar the sale, said Yiftah Shapir, head of the Middle East Military Balance assessment at the Institute for National Security Studies in Tel Aviv. “But by 2009 it had arrived.”
The Pantsir batteries were the newest layer of defense, complimenting the old Russian systems from the seventies and eighties. The Israeli news site Walla recently reported that Syria now has eight such batteries. The Wall Street Journal, quoting U.S. intelligence officials, put the number at 36.
The discrepancy may be part of the public battle over the quality of Syrian air defenses, which began in earnest in late April when an Israeli general revealed what most Western intelligence agencies apparently already knew: Assad’s soldiers had used sarin gas against rebel troops. This revelation, a clear crossing of President Barack Obama’s red line, pushed the U.S. closer to action in Syria and triggered a flood of leaks from the Pentagon.
When briefing the president or his staff, Gen. Martin Dempsey, the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, frequently singles out Syria’s air defenses as the single greatest obstacle to U.S. involvement in the conflict, the Wall Street Journal reported several days after the Israeli statement.
The paper quoted U.S. intelligence and defense officials as saying Assad’s air defense network was the most advanced and concentrated on the planet.
Rubin and Shapir agree that cumulative effect of the systems means Syria’s skies are densely protected but said that today, before the arrival of the S-300, the coverage is more tactical than strategic.
“The Pantsir units provide pinpoint coverage,” Shapir said, meaning the batteries defend only small swaths of the sky and only from close range.
Technologically, the Pantsir is state of the art. In June 2012, a Pantsir battery shot down an American-made Turkish Phantom F-4 jet somewhere near the countries’ borderline.
Yet judging by the airstrikes, reportedly by the IAF, in and around Damascus in January and earlier this month, their lock is easily picked. Many precision-guided strikes, said Shapir, appear to offer a path around the Pantsir.
This reportedly served Israel’s purpose of attacking specific weapons shipments. Establishing a no-fly zone – a constant blanket of air cover – is another story, as the Pantsir units are highly mobile and hard to track and could inflict losses on NATO aircraft.
Four units of the S-300 would further change the calculus. “They would cover all of Syrian airspace,” Rubin said, and “would be like a new lock on the safe.”
Rubin stressed that all locks can be picked and Israel and the U.S. possess the technological means to address such weapons systems, but he said they have yet to be tested on the S-300.
Al-Quds al-Arabi newspaper claimed Tuesday that Assad’s army actually already possesses the S-300 system, but that it is under Russian control. This cuts to the heart of the matter: the extent of Russian-Syrian cooperation. More than the technological ability of each weapons system, the very fact of Russian involvement on the ground – in terms of technical support and strategic backing – is pivotal.
“The surface-to-air missiles are a small problem,” Rubin said, with varying degrees of severity. “The big problem is Russia itself.”

Saturday, 23 March 2013

The Lebanese link in the chain of Assad days

Clockwise from right: Miqati, Erdogan, and Obama with Netanyahu, Abbas and King Abdullah

Is the fall of Lebanon’s “Hezbollah government” headed by Najib Miqati on the night U.S. President Barack Obama was closing out his visit to Israel, the West Bank and Jordan another nail in the coffin of Syrian President Bashar al-Assad’s regime?
Learned opinion suggests it is.
Miqati announced the resignation of his Hezbollah-dominated cabinet after it blocked approval of a commission to oversee planned parliamentary elections and procedures to extend the term of Internal Security Forces chief Ashraf Rifi.
Rifi and the Internal Security Forces have been in the gunsight of Hezbollah and its allies since the arrest last August of former government minister and Syria’s playmaker in Lebanon Michel Samaha.
Samaha was caught red-handed by Rifi’s second-in-command Wissam al-Hassan while smuggling explosives into Beirut from the Damascus office of Syrian Security Chief Ali Mamlouk in an attempt to destabilize Lebanon.
Samaha’s arrest led to Hassan’s swift assassination in October.
Within two months, the U.S. Treasury and State Department concurrently named Samaha as a “Specially Designated Global Terrorist” working on behalf of the Assad regime.
As Miqati was announcing his resignation in Beirut last night, Obama was telling a joint press conference with King Abdullah in Amman, “We are going to continue to closely consult with everybody in the region and do everything we can to bring an end to the bloodshed and to allow the Syrian people to get out from under the yoke of a leader who has lost all legitimacy because he is willing to slaughter his own people.  And I'm confident that Assad will go.  It's not a question of if. It’s when.”
While in Israel, Obama washed away some of the personal tension that existed between him and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, which in turn builds the necessary capital for coordinating with him on Iran and pressing him on the peace process and the two-state solution.
Obama said Israel and the U.S. agreed on the threat Iran posed, and the goal – to prevent Iran from acquiring a nuclear weapon. He said there was, however, still time to achieve this diplomatically.
He also succeeded in prodding Netanyahu to ring Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan and agree to end their three-year rift caused by a deadly Israeli commando raid on a Turkish ship bound for Gaza.
Following Obama’s visits to Israel and the West Bank, the Palestinian Authority was granted access to almost $500 million that was frozen by U.S. Congress for months.
In Amman, the U.S. president pledged to Jordan an extra $200m to help it deal with the growing number of Syrian refugees in the country.
Editorially, Ibrahim al-Amin, editor-in-chief of al-Akhbar daily, which speaks for Hezbollah, Iran and Assad, writes in his front-page leader today, “The details are many… But what’s certain is that Prime Minister Miqati’s resignation falls at the heart of the Syrian crisis.”
To his mind, the pointers and consequences are three each.
The pointers:
One:
Arab and international players hostile to the Syrian regime have been taking concrete steps, politically and on the ground, to ratchet up pressure on Damascus. For instance, they (a) frustrated (dialogue) initiatives by opposition figures such as Moaz al-Khatib (b) challenged provisions in the U.S.-Russian entente for a political solution in Syria (c) elected the prime minister of an interim government to take charge of Syria’s worldwide interests (d) trained and armed fighters with qualitative weapons in Syria, Turkey and Jordan in anticipation of a decisive battle against the regime within the coming three months.
Two:
The outcome of Obama’s visit to the region, where he urged the Palestinian Authority president to keep praying (for a two-state solution), pressed the king of Jordan to toe the anti-Assad line and called on Israel to reconcile with Turkey and to refrain from moving against Iran, Syria or Hezbollah.
Three:
A concerted American-European-Gulfite mobilization against Hezbollah by (a) invigorating the Special Tribunal for Lebanon (b) pushing the European Union to designate Hezbollah a terrorist organization (c) depicting Hezbollah as a threat to the livelihood of tens of thousands of Lebanese expatriates in the Arab world (d) prevailing on Miqati to undermine Hezbollah’s presence in the government (e) setting up a file labeled, “The role of Hezbollah in Syria.”
The three anticipated consequences of the aforesaid: (1) Security strains in Lebanon and along the Syrian-Lebanese borders (2) A chance that Hezbollah would take its eyes off the ball of helping the Assad regime (3) Political chaos in Lebanon and definite deferral of the parliamentary elections slated for June. 

Monday, 7 January 2013

Syria: Reading meticulously into Assad’s speech


Assad mobbed on stage by supporters at Damascus Opera House yesterday
For an insight into yesterday’s speech by Syria’s President Bashar al-Assad, I fancied this think piece by Abdelbari Atwan, publisher and editor-in-chief of the London-based daily al-Quds al-Arabi. He wrote it in Arabic:
Five indicative developments are worth contemplating in checking over the Syrian scene:
1.   The wordy speech delivered by President Assad yesterday, in which he thrashed out his plan for a peaceful end to the Syria crisis and his vision of the country’s future.
2.     The advisory issued by Saudi grand mufti Sheikh Abdulaziz Aal al-Shaykh to the kingdom’s mosque preachers. He directed them against inciting Saudi men to join the jihad in Syria, saying they should suffice with donations to Syrian insurgents through official Saudi channels.
3.     Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu’s pledge to erect a Golan fence to shut out global jihadists from Syria.
4.    Mounting complaints by Syria’s armed opposition led by the Free Syrian Army (FSA) that military and financial aid from Arab and foreign friends is tapering off.
5.     A meeting in Geneva later this month of Syrian opposition personas who support talks with the regime. Organizers say several European countries, including Germany, Switzerland and Sweden, back the gathering aimed at upholding Syria’s territorial integrity and demographic unity.
The five developments are interrelated and complementary. They foretell, in whole or in part, a reshaping of the Syrian scene.
-----
President Assad’s address disappointed his opponents. It didn’t sound like a speech by someone defeated and forced to go underground. His address was more forceful and eloquent than anything he delivered throughout the uprising.
And although he dwelt on and appreciated a political settlement, he delivered a preemptive blow to all political solutions currently on the table. That includes the Geneva initiative of the United States and Russia, which his regime had earlier accepted.
President Assad said clearly he wouldn’t negotiate with the overseas opposition, which he accused of being puppets of the West. He said if he wanted to talk, he would talk to their masters – or to the original copy, not the photocopy, as he put it.
He also reiterated he was staying put and won’t accept any request or hint to step down.
Judging from his address to the nation yesterday, here is a man who is determined to persist with his current approach to the tag end, regardless of the losses in human lives.
President Assad’s insistence on fighting jihadist groups – and Jabhat al-Nusra, which he deliberately avoided naming – was intended to (1) marginalize the external opposition and its internal offshoots (2) acknowledge the potency of jihadists on the ground, and (3) court Western countries, chiefly the United States, which had listed as terrorist some of the jihadist groups.
There are on the other hand three details in the speech that give away Assad’s state of self-denial:
1.     His offer of a political settlement featuring new elections, a new parliament, a new constitution and an all-embracing national dialogue is much the same as an acknowledgment that all his previous reform measures to try and appease the public convinced no one.
2.     His description of the Arab Spring as a soap bubble was overly simplistic. The Arab Spring, for instance, brought down an Egyptian regime that paralyzed the pan-Arab nation for 40 years… If it were not for the Arab Spring, President Assad would not have spoken of an all-embracing dialogue and new parliamentary elections or recognized the need to co-opt the internal opposition. It is also worth reminding that Assad, in the early days of the Arab Spring, incited people to revolt against regimes outside the so-called Axis of Resistance.
3.     His dismissal of the overseas opposition as a nonentity. The absence of an opposition in Syria is because the regime always kept its opponents in prisons and detention centers. Even internal opponents with whom he is willing to talk – such as Hassan Abdel-Azim, Aref Dalila and Luay Hussein – have all served time in jail and have been tortured either physically or morally before.
-----
President Assad is unlikely to fall without foreign military intervention. But such outside involvement is less likely, if not more doubtful, than ever before.
The U.S. administration fears the fallouts and can’t bear a humiliating outcome such as in Iraq and Afghanistan.
The Saudi grand mufti’s advisory, the Saudi foreign minister’s remarks yesterday (that the kingdom supports a peaceful solution in Syria, leaving the question of Assad’s exit to the Syrians to decide) and FSA grumbles about financial and military assistance drying out – all these are pointers that make the Syrian president less anxious about his fate than he has ever been.
Many predicted President Assad’s fall in 2012, either by the yearend or earlier. But with America playing it cool, with sectarian polarization rising and with mounting fears of Syria spillovers into neighboring countries such as Iraq, come about Israel’s Golan fence, the Saudi grand mufti’s advisory, Egypt’s indifference and instability in some Arab Spring countries.
All these are factors liable to extend the life of President Assad and his regime for another year, if not beyond.  God knows!