Pages

Monday, 23 January 2012

Full text: The Arab League’s Syria resolution



Following is my English wording of Sunday’s Arab League Resolution 7444 setting out a roadmap for peace in Syria.  The resolution declares after a brief preamble that the Arab League Council of Ministers DECIDED:

1. All acts of violence and killings from whatever source must stop, of necessity, to protect Syrian citizens.

2. To request the following from the Syrian government:
  • Release the detainees; clear all armed manifestations from cities and populated neighborhoods; give unhindered access to the pertinent League organizations and to the Arab and international media so they can move freely across Syria to ascertain the reality of conditions and monitor events on the ground.
  • Withdraw the Syrian army and any variety of armed forces back to their barracks and original positions.
  • Guarantee freedom of all manner of demonstrations and refrain from confronting demonstrators.
  • (The Council also) calls upon the Syrian government to facilitate the observers’ mission and permit the entry of all their equipment, chiefly telecommunications gear

3. To continue supporting, and to boost up the ranks of, the Arab League observer mission by providing it with the necessary technical, financial and administrative assistance in cooperation with the United Nations secretary-general.

4. To call upon the Syrian government and all opposition constituents to engage in a serious political dialogue under Arab League auspices within a maximum of two weeks from this date, the objective being:
  • Formation of a national unity government in conjunction with the opposition to be led by a consensual public figure within two months from this date. Its task would be to implement the Arab roadmap and pave the way for multiparty legislative and presidential elections by virtue of a law stipulating they be held under Arab and international supervision.
  • For the president of the Republic to give his first deputy comprehensive authority to fully cooperate with the national unity government so it can fulfill its duties in the transition period.
  • For the national unity government to declare as soon as it is formed that its objective is to establish a democratic and pluralistic system (of governance) in which all citizens are equal irrespective of their affiliations, sects and denominations and that the transfer of power is done peacefully.
  • For the national unity government to restore security and stability in the country and restructure and reinforce policing services so they can undertake security duties of a civic nature. The Arab states take it upon themselves to fund this endeavor in coordination with the Arab League.
  • Creation of an independent inquiry commission, which will be mandated to investigate and clear up abuses against citizens and decide on matters of redress for victims.

5. To direct the Arab League secretary-general to appoint a special envoy to follow through the political process.

6. To invite the international community to give a helping hand to the national unity government so it can fulfill its duties.

7. To ask the (Syria) committee chairman and the secretary-general to notify the Security Council of this plan pursuant to the Arab League resolutions.”

Saudi Arabia talks tough on Syria & Arab League


Syria has dismissed -- as an infringement on its sovereignty -- a peace roadmap hammered out by the Arab League foreign ministers while Saudi Arabia suggests the plan is stillborn and the League itself is incurable.

Saudi Arabia pulled out of the League's Syria observer mission, whose mandate was renewed for another month on Sunday, saying Damascus had broken promises on the earlier Arab peace protocol.

The new League proposal, to be presented to the United Nations Security Council for endorsement, mirrors the Gulf plan on Yemen that saw President Ali Abdullah Saleh agree to leave office. It calls on President Bashar al-Assad to delegate power to his vice-president to engage in proper dialogue with the opposition within two weeks, and form a national unity government in two months, followed by presidential and parliamentary elections.

Tariq Alhomayed, chief editor of the leading Saudi daily Asharq Alawsat, which reflects and articulates official Saudi thinking, wonders if there are other Arab takers of the kingdom’s position on Syria.

He writes this Monday morning:

Saudi Arabia has shut out all procrastinators, dawdlers and conspirators against the Syrian people and their revolution. It has shut out all those trying to bail out the tyrant Assad when its foreign minister announced the withdrawal of Saudi monitors from Syria and appealed to the international, Arab and Islamic communities to exert all efforts possible to spare Syrian blood.

Foreign Minister Saud al-Feisal went further. He received a Syrian opposition delegation led by Burhan Ghalioun while the Arab League’s ministerial panel on Syria was in conference. This means he sought to bring down the curtain on dilly-dallying in the Arab League. He showed Saudi Arabia was determined to exercise its leadership role in the Arab and Moslem worlds in order to safeguard Syrian blood. His meeting with the Syrian opposition effectively tore up Gen. Mohammed al-Dabi’s progress report on the observer mission he headed in Syria.

Dabi’s report comes across as being submitted to Assad, confirming that the Arab League is irremediable. The Arab League’s role is bound to become worse when Nouri al-Maliki’s Iraq assumes the League’s rotating chairmanship. A lifeline would be thrown to Assad then, since Tehran is now openly declaring that Iraq is in Iran’s sphere of influence.

Having said that, the way forward is (1) to set up a regional alliance comprising Saudi Arabia and its Gulf partners, Turkey and other willing Arab and non-Arab states to take charge of the Syria file, and (2) for the five other members of the GCC to follow in Saudi Arabia’s footsteps and meet with Burhan Ghalioun and co-opt the Syrian opposition.

Sunday, 22 January 2012

Sunday's Arab media newsreel


Headlines I selected from today’s Arab media:

Qatar’s Aljazeera
  • “95 killed in gory day in Syria”
  • “League set to extend observer mission, opposition primed for internationalization”
  • “Islamists control Egyptian parliament”

Lebanese daily as-Safir
  • “Tehran: Bringing down Damascus is an illusion and a mirage”

Lebanese daily an-Nahar
  • “Islamists sweep Egyptian parliament; ‘Revolution Continues’ party trails at the bottom”
  • “Yemen parliament approves immunity for Saleh, names Hadi as consensus candidate for president”
  • Columnist Ali Hamadeh: “Zabadani [city in Syria] and the Syrian revolution’s militarization”

Lebanese al-Manar TV
  • “Hamas: Leader Meshaal shunning re-election”

Saudi daily Asharq Alawsat
  • “Free Syrian Army said controlling north and east Idlib after fierce clashes with regime forces”
  • “Hezbollah elements manning Zabadani checkpoints -- activists”
  • Chief editor Tariq Alhomayed: “Syria’s Benghazi”

Egyptian daily al-Ahram
  • “Parliament: 127 list seats for Freedom and Justice, 96 for Nour, 36 for al-Wafd, 33 for Egyptian Bloc…”
  • “Mubarak can only be tried by a special court; constitutionally, he remains president to this day -- chief defense lawyer Farid al-Deeb”

Saudi daily al-Hayat
  • Columnist Hazem Saghiyeh: “Don’t execute him (Mubarak)”

Syrian daily Tishreen
  • “Real estate transactions at a standstill”
  • “Price of gas cylinder shoots up to 400 liras”
  • “80 percent of housing applicants now opting for illegal construction sites”

Assad clinches Russian writers’ award

Time Magazine cover by Shepard Fairey
Valery Ganichev (photo via Wikipedia)

The Russian Union of Writers, which groups some 7,500 Russian writers and authors, has just awarded Syrian President Bashar al-Assad an honorary prize for resolutely resisting “global hegemony in the political, social and government domains."

Syrian media, led by the state-run SANA (Syrian Arab News Agency) trumpet the news this morning.

They quote Russian Union of Writers chairman Valery Ganichev as saying: We've chosen to present the award to the president of the Syrian Arab Republic for his steadfastness in resisting the West's hegemony and attempts by modern day colonialists to impose their will on the generous, hardworking and great Syrian people.

As it has since 1927, Time Magazine selected its "Person of the Year" in December. The distinction goes to the person Time editors believe had the greatest impact during the previous 12 months, for good or for bad. In 2011, they chose: “The Protester” in honor of the Arab Spring, Occupy Wall Street and the Russian election rallies.

Saturday, 21 January 2012

“Highlights of the Syria observers’ report”


Arab observers in Syria (photo from Naharnet.com)

Lebanese daily an-Nahar publishes this morning what it claims to be the gist of the impending report to the Arab League on its observer mission to Syria.
The report by the mission's head, Sudanese Gen. Mohammed al-Dabi, will be discussed later today in Cairo by the League's Syria panel before the Arab Council of Foreign Ministers decides the mission's fate on Sunday.
Following are the highlights of Dabi's report according to an-Nahar:
  • The observers determined that Arab satellite TV news networks are “adequately” represented on the ground by the likes of (Saudi) Alarabiya, (Qatar’s) Aljazeera, (the UAE’s) Dubai, (Lebanese Hezbollah’s) al-Manar and (Iranian) Alalam.
  • There are also correspondents for the BBC, Algerian, German and Austrian television and for Turkish and British newspapers.
  • Syria proved “responsive” to the mission after the observer’s deployment. The opposition welcomed the observers, who also set citizens’ minds at rest.
  • A lone gunman flouted protocol provisions and fired at the observers and citizens.
  • The observers were subjected to a hostile media campaign described as “vicious and unprecedented.” This leads Dabi to believe there are sides seeking to frustrate the observer mission.
  • The report lists some breakthroughs by the mission, including the release (by the government) of a “not-insignificant” number of detainees and the withdrawal (by the army) of heavy armor and weapons from streets.
  • Dabi recognizes the observers were unable to stop the violence. He will put a request for armored vehicles and telecommunications equipment for his team.
  • Dabi will also enquire about purported mass defections of Syrian army regulars, having previously told the ministerial panel defections have so far been limited to new conscripts.

Friday, 20 January 2012

The cost of gagging Beirut (Part IV)



Riad Taha was president of the Lebanese Press Federation (LPF) for 13 years.

The first time we spoke was on the telephone, in April 1975.

The last time we spoke was also on the telephone, in July 1980 – the month he was machine-gunned mafia style after a car chase on Beirut’s seafront.

Born in Hermel in 1927, Riad Taha spent 38 years of his life in journalism – the last 13 of them as president of the LPF (grouping the Lebanese Publishers’ Union and Lebanese Journalists’ Union).

He received his education at the Jesuit School in Homs, Syria, the Oriental College in Zahle in Lebanon and the Patriarchal College in Beirut.

At the age of 15, while he was still a student in Homs, he put out his first publication – the al-Siraj literary magazine. Two years later, he put out another literary magazine, al-Awtar, and in 1945, he was named editor in chief of the al-Tala’eh magazine.

In 1947, he became co-owner of the Akhbar al-‘Alam political weekly, but the government suspended its publication after four months, because of its radical contents.

In 1949, he founded the first local news agency in Lebanon and the Middle East. He also published several dailies and weeklies (al-Ahad, al-Kifah, al-Afkar) during his long journalistic career, and a number of books.

In 1952, he survived an assassination attempt but was treated in hospital for several wounds. The LPF adopted the article that had led to the attempt on his life and published it in all Lebanese newspapers.

Some 30 bullets tore through Taha's Buick in Raouche
He was an outspoken critic of the country’s feudal leaders and struggled unceasingly for freedom of the Lebanese press. In one of his last statements, he said, “Journalists in Lebanon are laboring under a yoke of terror imposed by armed forces inside and outside the country.”

In 1967, he was elected LPF president, a position he held until his murder on July 23, 1980. His term had been renewed on December 19, 1979.

He was a candidate in parliamentary elections for the Baalbeck-Hermel district several times, but never made it to Parliament.

When Najib Azzam (see Part II in this series) was shot and killed in January, 1976, he wrote in Monday Morning: “I was stricken with grief at the loss of this friend and colleague, whom I consider one of the martyrs of the press and of freedom in this country… I shared the sorrow of the owner of Monday Morning, of the Monday Morning family, of the Azzam family over this tragedy. I was, like them, one of the bereaved.”

When Edouard Saab, editor of L’Orient-Le Jour was shot and killed in May 1976, Taha wrote in Monday Morning: “If in the West journalism is known as ‘the profession of trouble,’ we can rightly claim that for us in Lebanon, journalism is the profession of martyrdom.”

That statement was justified over and over, as one journalist after another succumbed to the Unidentified Gunmen infesting Lebanon.

Taha laid claim to martyrdom as he was driving through West Beirut to keep an appointment with then-outgoing Prime Minister Selim Hoss.

He left behind his own message to the Lebanese people.

“Without the freedom of the press,” he wrote, “it would not be long before all other freedoms in Lebanon vanished. How long would the freedom of political parties remain without the freedom of the press? What would happen to the freedom of assembly? All freedoms will soon wither and vanish without the freedom of the press.

 Taha behind his desk at the Lebanese Press Federaion
“So, I feel the fight for the freedom of the press should not be waged by the press alone. This is a public issue that will eventually affect the life of every citizen.”

Taha’s appeal to his people to throw their weight behind press freedom appeared in Monday Morning in November 1976. It was with the charge that some Arab countries were pressuring the Lebanese authorities into muzzling the press.

“There can be no doubt,” Taha wrote, “the majority of the Arab regimes, if not all of them, now favor applying pressure on the Lebanese authorities to abolish the freedom of the press in Lebanon, or to at least restrict it. Arab pressure toward the muzzling of the Lebanese press has started…

“Press freedom is unknown in the Arab countries and in nearly all the Third World… It is only natural that regimes that exercise some form of oppression should gang up against the free press of Lebanon, because it exposes their failings and reveals the truth about them. The free press of Lebanon is an embarrassment to other Arab countries…

“The final goal is not to restrict the freedom of the Lebanese press, but to abolish it.”

In another article written for Monday Morning, he enlarged on the theme as follows, “In a country like the United States, the safeguards are three: the Congress, the judiciary and the press. If any of these pillars is shaken, the system loses its foundation.  In Lebanon the press is the regime’s only safeguard. This is because our legislature is not discharging its duties, as neither is the judiciary. The Lebanese crisis has eclipsed the executive, legislative and judicial authorities… Only the press has survived. If this sole survivor is lost, the whole Lebanese system will lose its raison d’être…”

I first got to know Taha when I rang him in April 1975 to ask for an appointment. He received me at his LPF office and heard my complaint. I summed up my grievance as follows: “Political and armed infighting in the country leaves little apolitical content for my weekly magazine Monday Morning to publish. To cover politics in Monday Morning, I am required by law to buy an existing political publishing license, which I have already. I bought the title of weekly Al Shiraa from Monsignor Antoine Cortbawi. I applied to the Information Ministry for approval of the transfer of ownership of Al Shiraa so as to start using its title alongside Monday Morning’s. I also applied for membership in the Lebanese Publishers’ Union. The applications have gone unanswered for weeks although both are 100 percent aboveboard.”

Taha said he needed a couple of days to look into the matter. Within two weeks both applications were approved. I got the ministry’s approval and my Press Card in May 1975. With the Al Shiraa license legally under its belt, Monday Morning reworked its title page and turned political.

****

I bought the Al Shiraa title in 1975 from the late Mgr. Cortbawi through the good offices of my friend George Chami, now a distinguished and prolific novelist after a long mass media career.

Chami -- author of such novels as “What’s Left of (Civil) Strife,” (2003)  “Roots of Gold” (2005) and “Chinaberry Juice” (2008) – accompanied me to the meeting with Father Cortbawi at his vocational training and physiotherapy institute near Aley.

Mgr. Cortbawi accompanying my mother on a tour of his Institute
Before signing the transfer of ownership deed. Father Cortbawi told me: “You should know the Al Shiraa title is unadulterated. It was never on the market, not since I got it by a government decree signed some 25 years ago by (prime minister) Riad el-Solh. I’ll sign the deed of sale once you promise me not to use the title as a vehicle to undermine Lebanon.”

I made the promise. Father Cortbawi then took my check and looked at Chami, who nodded his head, signaling it was not a dud one. He then signed the deed, shook my hand and told me, “Congratulations. Now be safe!”

A year later, the Cortbawi Institute buildings near Aley were pillaged, scorched and left biting the dust by the Unidentified Gunmen.

Father Cortbawi died in 1979 but his institute is now thriving after being rebuilt in Adma.

****

From May 1975 until his murder in July 1980, Taha fended for the Lebanese press community. If he didn’t pay Monday Morning offices a surprise visit every couple of months, he would call to ask about the staff’s well being.

When magnetic tapes for our IBM Electronic "Selectric" Composer became unavailable in war-torn Lebanon, he made sure to bring a few on his return from trips to Europe.

Closure then of the English-language newspaper The Daily Star, and renewed hope the civil war was drawing to a close, drove me in March 1977 to consider publishing a new English-language daily as a stable mate to Monday Morning.

I consulted Taha on local press laws requiring every new political publication to buy a license off the market and keep the original name of that license.

He said he could think of an ideal title for an English daily that won’t need a name change, adding, “Since the title is parked with the owners, let me first find out if it is for sale.”

It was for sale.

After decades of publishing “Ayk” as an independent, nonpartisan Lebanese-Armenian newspaper, license owners Dikran and Lucie Tosbat sold me the title. I changed the spelling from “Ayk” – which means “dawn” in Armenian -- to “Ike” and started publishing it as an English- language daily in April 1977.

Riad Taha the painter at a 1974 New Year's party
What I called the newspaper mattered little. What I was offering was not a name but a service and for two years my staff did everything in their power to make the offering a worthy one. But the cycle of violence and the exodus from Lebanon caught up with Ike, which folded in mid-1979. In a country ravaged by civil war, it was easier to keep a weekly afloat than a weekly magazine and a daily newspaper at the same time.

Taha rang me a few weeks before his murder to say he was assembling an LPF delegation for a courtesy visit to the country’s president Suleiman Franjieh in Zghorta and invited me to join.

 I tried wriggling out, saying the roads were not safe. “Of course they’re not,” Taha said, “but we’ll be traveling by helicopter. Also your friend Jamil Alouf (a publisher from Zahle) will be joining us.”

I still declined the invite. Sadly, it was the last time we spoke.

In retrospect, I suspect Taha was trying in the weeks leading up to his death to appease his pro-Syrian antagonists.

The attempt proved futile. He was gunned down in Raouche, West Beirut, on Wednesday morning, July 23, 1980.

He left a widow, four sons and two daughters.


The cost of gagging Beirut (Part V) will be about the fifth victim, Janet Lee Stevens

Thursday, 19 January 2012

1976 flashback to Damascus and Moscow

Alexey Kosygin with Hafez Assad in Damascus  

Russia’s current stance on Syria evokes memories of a position the now-defunct Soviet Union took towards Damascus some 36 years ago.

Moscow today is effectively challenging much of the globe over Syria. It is sending shiploads of arms and ammunition to help it suppress the Syrian people. It flew the flag for it by deploying Russian warships to Tartus. And Moscow is vowing to block any UN resolution allowing sanctions or military actions against Damascus.

Rewind the clock to early 1976, when the Soviets got wind of Syrian President Hafez Assad’s plan to invade Lebanon. Soviet Prime Minister Akexey Kosygin flew to Damascus on June 1 to dissuade him. But hours before Kosygin’s arrival in the Syrian capital, the Syrian leader ordered his men and armor into Lebanon. Kosygin was thus faced with an accomplished fact, which Moscow took as an affront. Soviet condemnation of the invasion was not late in coming, culminating in suspending arms supplies to Syria. Advanced Soviet weaponry did not again reach Syria until 1978.