Pages

Showing posts with label Hafez al-Assad. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hafez al-Assad. Show all posts

Wednesday, 18 July 2012

Would Gen. Manaf Tlass ease Assad’s way out?


The Syria uprising entered a dramatic new phase with today’s killing in a bomb attack in the heart of Damascus of at least four of President Bashar al-Assad's top security aides.
They are Defense Minister Gen. Daoud Rajha; his deputy Assef Shawkat (who is Assad's brother-in-law); former defense minister and current Assistant Vice President Hassan Turkmani; and Hafez Makhlouf, head of Intelligence Agency investigations and brother of business tycoon Rami Makhlouf.
Several security officials were also seriously wounded in the attack, including Intelligence chief Hisham Bekhtyar and Interior Minister Mohammad Ibrahim al-Shaar.
The attack on the headquarters of Syria's National Security Council in the Rawda area is a deadly blow to the heart of the regime after two recent high-level defections – by Syria's ambassador to Iraq, Nawaf al-Faris, and a Republican Guard general, Manaf Tlass.
News of the devastating blow to Assad’s regime broke while I was working on the post below. For a while, I thought the post has probably been overtaken by events.
I doubt, but I leave it to the reader to judge:

Manaf Tlass (right) with Hafez and Bashar al-Assad
The Supreme Council of the Armed Forces (SCAF) oversaw the transition in Egypt from Hosni Mubarak to Mohamed Morsy.
Would world powers refine the SCAF template and choose a body of senior officers in the Syrian military to oversee a Syria transition plan?
If so, would Brig-Gen. Manaf Tlass, a Sunnite member of President Bashar al-Assad’s inner circle and commander of one of Syria’s elite Republic Guard units who moved to France earlier this month, turn into Syria’s Hussein Tantawi?
Tlass yesterday called for a political transition in Syria and condemned military attacks on civilians in a statement sent to AFP.
Expressing anger that security forces were being used to suppress dissent, he said the regime held “the major responsibility” for the crisis and confirmed he was in Paris.
“I sincerely hope the blood stops flowing and the country emerges from the crisis through a phase of constructive transition that guarantees Syria its unity, stability and security, as well as the aspirations of its people,” said Tlass, a childhood friend of Assad.
“I am ready like any other Syrian, with no other ambition, to fulfill my civic duty to contribute to a better future for my country, as much as I can, and like all those... who have already made many sacrifices,” he said.
However, he did not specifically call for Assad to step down or say he was joining the Syrian opposition.
“I cannot but express my anger and pain at seeing the army pushed to carry out a fight that is against its principles, a fight directed by security forces and in which the people, including the soldiers, are the victims,” he said.
“When I took a position and refused to take part in the security action, I was isolated, accused and even labeled a traitor,” he said. “But my conscience, my deep conviction, pushed me to challenge this destructive action and to distance myself.”
Tlass said in the statement sent to AFP: “Faithful to my country and my beliefs, I always tried over the past 18 months to do my duty, unfortunately without success. I was not complacent with the regime, I did not accept nor participate in an action that led the country to its current tragic situation.”
Writing for today’s edition of the Lebanese pro-Assad daily al-Akhbar, Nasser Sharara gives an invaluable insight into the reasons behind Tlass’ flight to France.
My synopsis of Sharara’s 1,700-word account:
To this day, the way Manaf Tlass left Damascus remains a mystery to the Syrian security services.
He may have left via Lebanon. What is certain is that on the day news broke of Manaf having left Syria, his wife and young son who were in Beirut were driven by “M.H.” to Rafik Hariri International airport. There, they boarded a flight to Paris under their real names: “Tala Ahmad Khair (maiden name of Manaf’s wife) and (her son) Ahmed Manaf Tlass.”
In Damascus, however, officials still have reservations about calling Manaf a “traitor.” It seems “they’re still betting on keeping him close to President Assad whether he returns to Syria or stays abroad.”
Manaf did not break with Assad. He kept saying his clash was with the security services bigwigs who had Assad’s ear.
He complained to visitors, “The three closest persons to the late Hafez Assad were Sunnites. With the president now, I rank ninth.”
Manaf’s disaffection was with “the political solution saboteurs.” Media reports that he sulked at home after taking off his military uniform are false. Even when slamming “spoilers” in the security services, he kept turning out at his office in the presidential palace and at the headquarters of Presidential Guard Unit #105, which he commanded.
Throughout his disaffection, Manaf remained in contact and on good terms with Assad, whom he always addressed as “Boss.” He also kept repeating, “I can play the role of a go-between, connecting the Sunnite opposition in particular with President Assad. I played that role before. The Boss mandated me earlier to do just that. But opponents of a political solution sabotaged my task for fear of losing their vested interests in case a settlement is reached. That’s why I bowed out.”
In early 2012, Manaf got wind of a Moscow-backed suggestion by world stakeholders to solve the Syria crisis by a agreeing a mixed military council to oversee a political transition. The council would consist of officers from the various sects and mirror Egypt’s SCAF. People who heard him discuss this felt he was thrilled by the idea, “perhaps because he was promised a key role in the council.”
Recommended link:

Friday, 20 April 2012

“Syria is fragmenting, says American facilitator”


Syria map from www.bbc.co.uk

In May 2008, both Israel under Ehud Olmert and Syria under Bashar al-Assad acknowledged they were holding indirect talks to reach a comprehensive peace agreement. The talks were suspended seven months later.
An American facilitator of these and of earlier negotiations between the two sides, talking to Lebanese daily an-Nahar’s authoritative political analyst Sarkis Naoum, gives this assessment of the Syria crisis:
****
Yes, the Syrian civil war is in progress. It will continue and expand. The regime is down but now out.
Much blood will be shed in Syria. If political agreement were not reached, Syria would fragment. The regime and its people would decamp to the Alawite Mountains and hold on to the cities along the coastal plain and maybe other places. An Alawite state, canton or the like could emerge. From there on, God knows what!
The 1982 crackdown on Hama and events preceding it alarmed Hafez al-Assad. He was afraid he wouldn’t come out on top. He opened a main branch for the Syrian Central Bank in the Alawite region, where he also built universities and vital infrastructures. He wanted the area all set in case he needed to relocate there. At the time, he transferred all the Central Bank’s foreign currency reserves to the (regional) branch. What can prevent this, or something similar, happening today?
I know the Syrian regime well. I was in contact with the late president and then with his son, the current president. We worked together on peace with Israel.
Some 7,000 people have been killed in Syria so far. Blood is being shed. Bashar can’t carry on. But he can’t walk away either. He has blood on his hands. He is not in charge. Those around him are in charge.
Assad and Powell in May 2003
When he received Colin Powell a few years back (in May 2003), he promised him many things that were never implemented. The people around him wouldn’t let him. They told him: you are the president, but don’t take decisions and don’t make promises because you can’t see them through.
The interview he gave Barbara Walters (last December) proves he controls nothing.
Sarkis Naoum: Does his inner circle, especially its Alawites, support him?
Some Alawite top brass might desert him. They could join the revolution if it takes them in. Or they could simply stay home, now that the uprising/revolution has taken a sectarian character. Maybe a significant proportion of Alawites don’t approve of Bashar’s policy. Some possibly hate him. But they cling on for fear of Sunnite factionalism, chiefly the Muslim Brothers and Salafists.
Imagine that sectarianism has now engulfed Syrian expatriates in France.  Medical staff at a French hospital included 13 Syrian doctors – 12 Sunnites and one Alawite. They were friends and worked together. Since the revolution, the 12 wouldn’t talk to the 13th. Here, in my country, the United States, resident Alawites are not invited to Syrian opposition meetings.
The U.S. and the West have to find a solution to the Syrian crisis so as to spare Syrian blood and preempt Syria fragmenting. But that’s not their priority. They won’t intervene militarily. They could be supplying or allowing the supply of arms and funds (to the Syrian opposition).
America was unequivocal when it urged Assad to stand down, ruling out dialogue with him. Had he been ready for a settlement in the first months of the crisis he could have saved his skin.
Naoum: Does the Syrian regime still reach out to you? What does it ask of the United States?
There is contact. He wants America to lay off his back. Is such a request plausible? Assad makes no sensible request and proposes nothing practical.
Naoum: Is Assad Iran’s ally or its captive?
He was Iran’s ally. He is now its captive. His father was an ally and a full partner (of Iran). He (Bashar) is a small partner. He can refuse Iran nothing because of its comprehensive cash, arms and training assistance.
The Russians, who support his war on people seeking to oust him, neither ask him to step down nor facilitate his choice of compromise should he make one.
The Syrian National Council (SNC) is not fully representative. Many of its members reside in the West. Some are in Turkey. Others are in Arab capitals. Some emigrated overseas a long time ago. Others were forced into exile lately. And they have differences of opinion on their role and eminence.
The true representatives of the insurgent Syrian people are the Local Coordination Committees and the Free Syrian Army.